I've made similar posts before and I am glad to say that I have not been wrong so far *grin*. However, I haven't been as precise as I will be in this post, I think.
Right now I am quite confident that I can predict three precise scenarios of the future of the European Union, more specifically of the European Monetary Union, the Euro.
(1)
This is the least likely scenario. The large Mediterranean countries, Italy, Spain and France, consolidate their finances. A low, but stable economic growth sets in. China continues to grow fast for at least the next 10 years (unlikely). With support of all institutions, including the ECB, speculators are less and less able to create panic. Eventually the crisis will be over and Europe will mostly look like it looked five years ago.
(2)
This is the second likely scenario. The crisis hits us hard within the next 18 months. Germany has to choose between chaos and Eurobonds. In this scenario our current government, supported by most of the opposition, will draw all jokers and push through Eurobonds, no matter what the population thinks about it. This may be political suicide for the currently governing (conservative) parties, but it will instantly solve the current crisis.
If badly done it will also create a lot of moral hazard that will come back a decade later and kick our asses. Anyway, the current crisis is solved by Eurobonds. In fact, Europeans will find out that the interest rates for the Eurobonds will be as low as the one for U.S. bonds, because it just doesn't make sense to speculate against the Titanic while you are on it. U.S. bonds' interest rates would, however, raise slightly, because there's suddenly an alternative. In my opinion, this is the best scenario. Most people would agree with me a few years later.
(3)
This is the most likely scenario, unfortunately. Somehow the crisis is held at bay with the help of the ECB and inflation. However, it lingers in the background for years to come. Eventually it will turn out that one of the large Mediterranean countries is insolvent. However, the long time that has passed, has allowed many Euro-sceptic parties to take seat in the national parliaments. They will not introduce Eurobonds, because that's the prime reason they have been elected by an ignorant population. The monetary union will dissolve and economic consequences around the world will be drastic. Germany's GDP temporarily drops by 20-30%. Political consequences are unpredictable. A third European/world war, however, is impossible due to globalized trade.
We return to the patchwork landscape Europe is famous for. Two decades later most European countries have a nice standard of living, maybe even higher than under scenario (2). European influence on global politics, however, shrinks to an all-time low and remains there for the rest of the century.
One word about a potential forth scenario that includes the creation of a northern European monetary union or the forceful exclusion of Greece. This scenario would cause great harm to all Mediterranean countries and serious harm to the rest of the world; it would transform Greece into a third world country.
Most Germans think that Greece only has to blame itself. That may be so. However, after starting two world/European wars, Germany would never want to have this on its conscience. Historians would rightfully note that Germany blew up the European project. It's morally unacceptable - unthinkable.
A northern European monetary union might be created in the aftermath of scenario (3). But that's pure speculation.
Scenario (2) is the current direction of German media. Even traditionally euro-sceptic newspapers are reassessing the potential of Eurobonds. It is also for reasons of pride that I favour it.
No matter what happens, this is the world's history in the making!
---
* Note: A "Eurobond" within the context of this crisis is a bond that is issued and guaranteed by all countries inside the Eurozone. That is how the newspapers use the term. Wikipedia defines the term differently.
Saturday, August 13, 2011
Friday, August 12, 2011
Insuring your Neighbor's House
(1)
Imagine you want to insure yourself against your house burning to the ground. How do you do that? Well, in a free market you buy a contract from a financial institution.
The contract says:
"Institution X pays the owner of this contract 100.000 Euros should house Y burn down."
This is great for both of you! Institution X probably can take the risk that your house Y might in fact burn down. And you couldn't bear that risk. That's why you just payed money to get that contract. Instead of having a 99% chance of not going bankrupt and a 1% chance of going bankrupt, you pay a small fee so that you can never go bankrupt.
Wonderful free markets at work!
Actually you might also want to buy that contract for your neighbor's house. Why? Well, perhaps because you are pretty sure that his house is going to burn down soon ...
And we see: Insurance is great, as long as you own what you insure ..
(2)
Imagine you have a lot of money. And you want more money. Now, you could insure yourself against French bonds becoming worthless (France going bankrupt). Luckily somebody has created a contract:
The contract says:
"Institution X pays the owner of this contract 1 Mio Dollars should French bonds become worthless."
Let's assume you buy lots and lots of these contracts. Now, you already bought French bonds over a long time. But you're not stupid. Of course you don't want to own French bonds, anymore. In fact, you sell all of them; at the same time!
French bonds drop by 5% due to this. A lot of people see that and, since they are nervous for other reasons, they sell, too.
Due to that drop a lot more people want to insure themselves against the bonds becoming worthless. And they are willing to pay more money to buy the contracts.
Now, you lost a limited amount of money by first buying the French bonds over a long time and then selling them all at once at up to 5% less. But you also gain a lot of money from selling the insurance contracts. And this money is without limit. You could have bought as many of these contracts as you desired!
And that's why insurance papers, like Credit Default Swaps (CDS), are great as long as the owner owns what he insures, but terrible, if he does not. I'm not the first guy to find out. Warren Buffet called CDS "financial weapons of mass destruction". .. in 2003!
(3)
Why am I unable to buy insurance contracts for my neighbor's house? Because no sane institution would sell me papers that insured my neighbor's house. Just like no institution offers insurance against divorce. And that's the difference between these two markets.
The institutions that create bond-insuring contracts are actually performing terribly (banks, for example). But the people in charge do great. They make great money from selling the contracts and should the insured event occur, the government saves their employer with tax-dollars.
Hell - and even if not! They just got their bonus for selling a million contracts. Moral hazard at work.
Imagine you want to insure yourself against your house burning to the ground. How do you do that? Well, in a free market you buy a contract from a financial institution.
The contract says:
"Institution X pays the owner of this contract 100.000 Euros should house Y burn down."
This is great for both of you! Institution X probably can take the risk that your house Y might in fact burn down. And you couldn't bear that risk. That's why you just payed money to get that contract. Instead of having a 99% chance of not going bankrupt and a 1% chance of going bankrupt, you pay a small fee so that you can never go bankrupt.
Wonderful free markets at work!
Actually you might also want to buy that contract for your neighbor's house. Why? Well, perhaps because you are pretty sure that his house is going to burn down soon ...
And we see: Insurance is great, as long as you own what you insure ..
(2)
Imagine you have a lot of money. And you want more money. Now, you could insure yourself against French bonds becoming worthless (France going bankrupt). Luckily somebody has created a contract:
The contract says:
"Institution X pays the owner of this contract 1 Mio Dollars should French bonds become worthless."
Let's assume you buy lots and lots of these contracts. Now, you already bought French bonds over a long time. But you're not stupid. Of course you don't want to own French bonds, anymore. In fact, you sell all of them; at the same time!
French bonds drop by 5% due to this. A lot of people see that and, since they are nervous for other reasons, they sell, too.
Due to that drop a lot more people want to insure themselves against the bonds becoming worthless. And they are willing to pay more money to buy the contracts.
Now, you lost a limited amount of money by first buying the French bonds over a long time and then selling them all at once at up to 5% less. But you also gain a lot of money from selling the insurance contracts. And this money is without limit. You could have bought as many of these contracts as you desired!
And that's why insurance papers, like Credit Default Swaps (CDS), are great as long as the owner owns what he insures, but terrible, if he does not. I'm not the first guy to find out. Warren Buffet called CDS "financial weapons of mass destruction". .. in 2003!
(3)
Why am I unable to buy insurance contracts for my neighbor's house? Because no sane institution would sell me papers that insured my neighbor's house. Just like no institution offers insurance against divorce. And that's the difference between these two markets.
The institutions that create bond-insuring contracts are actually performing terribly (banks, for example). But the people in charge do great. They make great money from selling the contracts and should the insured event occur, the government saves their employer with tax-dollars.
Hell - and even if not! They just got their bonus for selling a million contracts. Moral hazard at work.
The Mana Mechanic
In the far past magic was considered to be more powerful than non-magic. Unfortunately this lead to too many players wanting to play magic users. Thus, if a fantasy story was to be transfered into a game setting, and if the game designer wanted to allow everybody to potentially play a magic user, he had to balance magic.
Mana is the traditional choice. The magic user can be more powerful than non-magic users, but he exhausts very fast. This was a simple mechanic with a reasonable simulation aspect that introduced interesting decisions in table-top RPGs. Great.
Unfortunately it doesn't really work with modern MMORPGs. The problem is mostly with PvP. (But while raiding the mechanic is problematic, as well). The fact that dying in most PvP mini-games (like battlegrounds) is mostly meaningless, makes the mana mechanic useless.
If the magic user were overpowered while he has mana and underpowered while he has no mana, the result would be a very boring battleground: The magic user would defeat non-magic users until he is out-of-mana, at which point he is defeated by somebody else. Revive. Repeat. Very boring.
Because game designers nowadays cannot (are not allowed to) think out-of-the-box, they didn't replace the mechanic, but iterated it over the last decade. This lead to magic users that have almost infinite amounts of mana and are actually balanced while they have mana. Should they run out-of-mana, they are extremely underpowered, but since this almost never happens, it's not a problem.
This is an unnecessarily complicated mechanic that doesn't introduce interesting decisions and doesn't even balance powerful magic. If you could play a PvP-specced mage in a WoW battleground who had endless amounts of mana, you wouldn't feel a difference, really.
Ok, you could try to arcane-blast everything to death. But actually .. isn't that what's happening and forcing Blizzard to re-balance arcane blast all the time? If a mage were balanced while fighting in a mana-saving way, he were overpowered, because he could just as well fight in a non-mana-saving way. And, of course, most mages would do just that. Which would cause lots and lots of complaining about OP mages in the forums. And this wouldn't even be unreasonable.
The mana mechanic doesn't work in a PvP game that has 30s respawns. It requires harsh death penalties (remember tabletops!) to work. Thus, we could either introduce harsher death penalties, or we could use a different magic system.
Mana is the traditional choice. The magic user can be more powerful than non-magic users, but he exhausts very fast. This was a simple mechanic with a reasonable simulation aspect that introduced interesting decisions in table-top RPGs. Great.
Unfortunately it doesn't really work with modern MMORPGs. The problem is mostly with PvP. (But while raiding the mechanic is problematic, as well). The fact that dying in most PvP mini-games (like battlegrounds) is mostly meaningless, makes the mana mechanic useless.
If the magic user were overpowered while he has mana and underpowered while he has no mana, the result would be a very boring battleground: The magic user would defeat non-magic users until he is out-of-mana, at which point he is defeated by somebody else. Revive. Repeat. Very boring.
Because game designers nowadays cannot (are not allowed to) think out-of-the-box, they didn't replace the mechanic, but iterated it over the last decade. This lead to magic users that have almost infinite amounts of mana and are actually balanced while they have mana. Should they run out-of-mana, they are extremely underpowered, but since this almost never happens, it's not a problem.
This is an unnecessarily complicated mechanic that doesn't introduce interesting decisions and doesn't even balance powerful magic. If you could play a PvP-specced mage in a WoW battleground who had endless amounts of mana, you wouldn't feel a difference, really.
Ok, you could try to arcane-blast everything to death. But actually .. isn't that what's happening and forcing Blizzard to re-balance arcane blast all the time? If a mage were balanced while fighting in a mana-saving way, he were overpowered, because he could just as well fight in a non-mana-saving way. And, of course, most mages would do just that. Which would cause lots and lots of complaining about OP mages in the forums. And this wouldn't even be unreasonable.
The mana mechanic doesn't work in a PvP game that has 30s respawns. It requires harsh death penalties (remember tabletops!) to work. Thus, we could either introduce harsher death penalties, or we could use a different magic system.
Saturday, August 6, 2011
The Crisis of Credit
This video is two years old and nowadays we have different problems. But it is a masterpiece at explaining the most important reason for the 2008/2009 crisis.
Do you know similar videos for the current crises?
Do you know similar videos for the current crises?
Friday, August 5, 2011
Funny, ...
... if it weren't your money ...
http://aktien-boersen.blogspot.com/2010/05/crash-emotionen-live-mitschnitt-vom.html
I was remembered of this.
http://aktien-boersen.blogspot.com/2010/05/crash-emotionen-live-mitschnitt-vom.html
I was remembered of this.
Thursday, August 4, 2011
When Compromise Fails
We're in trouble. I'm saying this for quite some time now. Certainly I feel like being in trouble after watching part of my money melt at 0.3% the hour today. Was a hell of a lot of fun !
.. Europeans are great at compromise. We can get 17 parties at a table with 17 different opinions and walk out pretending that the found solution, while not the best, is good enough. According to U.S. media we live in paradise.
And in many respects we are. But sometimes every now and then there's a problem that cannot be solved with compromise.
.. The U.S. debt crisis is not such a problem. All parties agree that debt has to be reduced and the question is just what has to be cut and what (whether, lol) taxes have to be raised. You can find any compromise here and it's (comparatively) ok. Sure, if you don't do anything you obliterate yourself, but anything else is (kind of) a solution.
The European debt crisis is different. There are two opposed positions and a third way that is the 'compromise'. Unfortunately, that third way is by far the worst. Not just for Europe, but every single human on this planet.
Solution #1 is to create a European Super-state; most powerful economic zone on Earth. Sounds great - but not everybody likes that. It means that Germans have to pay for Greek debt. And there are a lot of institutional problems to be solved. We need some kind of constitution, right? Future moral hazard has to be prevented. We would need to have elections.
Getting something like this right is not easy and it does take a lot of time, even if all parties agreed. Of course, they don't. And we don't have time.
Solution #2 is to split the Euro Zone up again. This is a bit easier to do from an institutional point of view. Unfortunately, it also means that a lot of banks go bankrupt and this would probably lead to a world-wide second great depression. But at least this process could be organized.
And then there's the compromise: We chain ourselves together and at the same time split up ... yeah, right.
Now, this is just as bad as doing nothing! The parliaments of countries like Germany, Netherlands, Austria or Finland might soon not allow their governments to spend the peoples' money at the necessary rate to save Greece, Portugal, Ireland, Spain or Italy. And if that happens we have numerous unorganized bankruptcies. This will also lead to a second great depression. Just that we would probably have to invent a new name for this kind of crisis.
Right now, we are going straight for the third way; the holy compromise. But not all problems can be solved by compromise .. We need a tea party: a party that somehow manages to push the own agenda through - any agenda - in a totally undemocratic way.
.. Europeans are great at compromise. We can get 17 parties at a table with 17 different opinions and walk out pretending that the found solution, while not the best, is good enough. According to U.S. media we live in paradise.
And in many respects we are. But sometimes every now and then there's a problem that cannot be solved with compromise.
.. The U.S. debt crisis is not such a problem. All parties agree that debt has to be reduced and the question is just what has to be cut and what (whether, lol) taxes have to be raised. You can find any compromise here and it's (comparatively) ok. Sure, if you don't do anything you obliterate yourself, but anything else is (kind of) a solution.
The European debt crisis is different. There are two opposed positions and a third way that is the 'compromise'. Unfortunately, that third way is by far the worst. Not just for Europe, but every single human on this planet.
Solution #1 is to create a European Super-state; most powerful economic zone on Earth. Sounds great - but not everybody likes that. It means that Germans have to pay for Greek debt. And there are a lot of institutional problems to be solved. We need some kind of constitution, right? Future moral hazard has to be prevented. We would need to have elections.
Getting something like this right is not easy and it does take a lot of time, even if all parties agreed. Of course, they don't. And we don't have time.
Solution #2 is to split the Euro Zone up again. This is a bit easier to do from an institutional point of view. Unfortunately, it also means that a lot of banks go bankrupt and this would probably lead to a world-wide second great depression. But at least this process could be organized.
And then there's the compromise: We chain ourselves together and at the same time split up ... yeah, right.
Now, this is just as bad as doing nothing! The parliaments of countries like Germany, Netherlands, Austria or Finland might soon not allow their governments to spend the peoples' money at the necessary rate to save Greece, Portugal, Ireland, Spain or Italy. And if that happens we have numerous unorganized bankruptcies. This will also lead to a second great depression. Just that we would probably have to invent a new name for this kind of crisis.
Right now, we are going straight for the third way; the holy compromise. But not all problems can be solved by compromise .. We need a tea party: a party that somehow manages to push the own agenda through - any agenda - in a totally undemocratic way.
Diablo 3 RMT, again
I am running out of titles. The more I think about Blizzard's 'new' RMT solution, the more fascinated I am.
Just a few moments ago I found myself thinking:
"Imagine you find this Pet-Of-Überness while you play hardcore mode. Wouldn't it suck to not be able to sell it?"
Remember, I usually hate RMT in games. And still, the idea that you can actually make money by skillful and serious playing is fascinating me. Even though I hate myself for it.
We all consider ourselves skillful and serious players - otherwise we wouldn't read/write MMO blogs. Actually, most of us probably are skilled, because to become skilled in games you mostly need to be motivated and invest a lot of time. And that's what those who read/write gaming blogs do.
But my point is: if even I think along these lines, imagine the average guy ..
I have a feeling (fear) that Diablo 3 is going to be the next business-defining game made by Blizzard. Respect.
Forget the old microtransactions. The new system is light-years better for making money. In the past, many players had problems justifying the time they spent in games. Especially if they were married. But now, suddenly, they can make a bit of money while playing, while the single upper-middleclass guy can finally spend all that money that he can't get rid of during his 50-hours work-week.
Didn't it suck in the past that you earned so much money working your day job and couldn't benefit from it in your daily hobby? If Diablo 3 is a Blizzard quality game with this kind of RMT, it will hit like a bomb, I think.
The traditional microtransactions felt too much like an outside intrusion. The money-making scam that selling virtual items is, left too much of a bad taste in most peoples' mouth. Buying virtual items felt wasteful and was only going to make the company rich although creating the virtual item doesn't cost anything.
But the D3 RMT feels not so much like a scam. The $-AH just redistributes the items that have been found in the game. And that small fee Blizzard wants feels totally ok.
And items are never overpriced - by definition. You are just stupid if you let other players fool you. No way to blame Blizzard.
And it's more than just a game. If you never buy anything, you will be able to earn a bit of money. And rather consistently! That's more than just a game. It is some hobby that can make you money (even if you end up paying more than you earn - the feeling matters).
In the past we were addicted to advancing our characters - finding that one über-cool item. In the future we will be addicted to advancing our finances. This is the oldest business in the world. And it works so damn well that it is heavily regulated nowadays - even in unlikely places like the U.S. !
The possibility to earn money (even if it's just a theoretical possibility) is a game changer, literally!
Unfortunately, Blizzard shares are listed in dollars. What do I want with dollars ?
Just a few moments ago I found myself thinking:
"Imagine you find this Pet-Of-Überness while you play hardcore mode. Wouldn't it suck to not be able to sell it?"
Remember, I usually hate RMT in games. And still, the idea that you can actually make money by skillful and serious playing is fascinating me. Even though I hate myself for it.
We all consider ourselves skillful and serious players - otherwise we wouldn't read/write MMO blogs. Actually, most of us probably are skilled, because to become skilled in games you mostly need to be motivated and invest a lot of time. And that's what those who read/write gaming blogs do.
But my point is: if even I think along these lines, imagine the average guy ..
I have a feeling (fear) that Diablo 3 is going to be the next business-defining game made by Blizzard. Respect.
Forget the old microtransactions. The new system is light-years better for making money. In the past, many players had problems justifying the time they spent in games. Especially if they were married. But now, suddenly, they can make a bit of money while playing, while the single upper-middleclass guy can finally spend all that money that he can't get rid of during his 50-hours work-week.
Didn't it suck in the past that you earned so much money working your day job and couldn't benefit from it in your daily hobby? If Diablo 3 is a Blizzard quality game with this kind of RMT, it will hit like a bomb, I think.
The traditional microtransactions felt too much like an outside intrusion. The money-making scam that selling virtual items is, left too much of a bad taste in most peoples' mouth. Buying virtual items felt wasteful and was only going to make the company rich although creating the virtual item doesn't cost anything.
But the D3 RMT feels not so much like a scam. The $-AH just redistributes the items that have been found in the game. And that small fee Blizzard wants feels totally ok.
And items are never overpriced - by definition. You are just stupid if you let other players fool you. No way to blame Blizzard.
And it's more than just a game. If you never buy anything, you will be able to earn a bit of money. And rather consistently! That's more than just a game. It is some hobby that can make you money (even if you end up paying more than you earn - the feeling matters).
In the past we were addicted to advancing our characters - finding that one über-cool item. In the future we will be addicted to advancing our finances. This is the oldest business in the world. And it works so damn well that it is heavily regulated nowadays - even in unlikely places like the U.S. !
The possibility to earn money (even if it's just a theoretical possibility) is a game changer, literally!
Unfortunately, Blizzard shares are listed in dollars. What do I want with dollars ?
Diablo 3 RMT Prices
What will Diablo 3 RMT prices be?
Well, most players, even if they put most of what they find into the $-AH, will make almost no money. If any at all. Some hardcore players will make a few dollars. Some really hardcore players will make a few hundred dollars.
But only some lucky players will make a thousand and more. You will not be one of them.
At all time there will be many items on the $-AH that go for $20-$80. If not, all market research of microtransaction companies has been wrong. It will be interesting to find out whether they were right. I think they could ask more than just $80 for a monocle.
Now, if Blizzard is serious about the amount of revenue they make with fees, they will do everything they can to prevent those 5% of the players, who are willing to pay money, from running out of reasons to do so.
There are two ways to accomplish this: Either some items are incredibly rare, or we get WoW-like tiers of items.
"Incredibly rare" items means so rare, that your chance to find one is so small that it is safe to assume that you will never find one, no matter how much you play. Therefore, the only players to ever own one are the ones who really spend massive amounts of money on the game. And after they did this, they stop spending money.
Now, Blizzard will argue that it is not fair that the best items go only to the richest player. What they really think, of course, is that they don't want the richest players to only ever buy an item once. And so we will get a tiered system like WoW.
With a tiered system the richest players will be encouraged to buy the best items again and again every few months! And it's even more fair, is it not? See how RMT is not just a business model, but changes the game ?
---
About immersion and stuff. I really don't find this kind of $-AH as bad as normal microtransactions. To know that every item has a history inside the game is just great. Sure, it's much worse than a game in which characters got what they have due to in-game actions. But if you really desperately want RMT, do it this way.
---
What I don't really understand is how Blizzard expects to get through with this legally. Fact of the matter is that playing Diablo 3 will be as difficult as using a slot machine. And if you're lucky you can get a lot of money that less lucky players put into the machine. .. That's gambling ..
Well, most players, even if they put most of what they find into the $-AH, will make almost no money. If any at all. Some hardcore players will make a few dollars. Some really hardcore players will make a few hundred dollars.
But only some lucky players will make a thousand and more. You will not be one of them.
At all time there will be many items on the $-AH that go for $20-$80. If not, all market research of microtransaction companies has been wrong. It will be interesting to find out whether they were right. I think they could ask more than just $80 for a monocle.
Now, if Blizzard is serious about the amount of revenue they make with fees, they will do everything they can to prevent those 5% of the players, who are willing to pay money, from running out of reasons to do so.
There are two ways to accomplish this: Either some items are incredibly rare, or we get WoW-like tiers of items.
"Incredibly rare" items means so rare, that your chance to find one is so small that it is safe to assume that you will never find one, no matter how much you play. Therefore, the only players to ever own one are the ones who really spend massive amounts of money on the game. And after they did this, they stop spending money.
Now, Blizzard will argue that it is not fair that the best items go only to the richest player. What they really think, of course, is that they don't want the richest players to only ever buy an item once. And so we will get a tiered system like WoW.
With a tiered system the richest players will be encouraged to buy the best items again and again every few months! And it's even more fair, is it not? See how RMT is not just a business model, but changes the game ?
---
About immersion and stuff. I really don't find this kind of $-AH as bad as normal microtransactions. To know that every item has a history inside the game is just great. Sure, it's much worse than a game in which characters got what they have due to in-game actions. But if you really desperately want RMT, do it this way.
---
What I don't really understand is how Blizzard expects to get through with this legally. Fact of the matter is that playing Diablo 3 will be as difficult as using a slot machine. And if you're lucky you can get a lot of money that less lucky players put into the machine. .. That's gambling ..
Wednesday, August 3, 2011
Eve Online Lessons Learned
CCP has published a nice dev blog.
Among other things there are Lessons Learnt. Most of these apply to any game.
Among other things there are Lessons Learnt. Most of these apply to any game.
Having to do something tedious every day before you can actually play the game is not cool.
As a dev, doing something just "because it would be cool/neat/awesome" is always a bad idea and will come back to bite you later.
Cost is a useful variable to tune but an unwise thing to rely on to enforce scarcity or balance - players will always be richer than you think.
Making something tedious will not stop players doing it if it's very clearly the best option. They'll do it, and they'll hate it.
People like to do one-stop shopping, and will "go to Jita" for everything unless doing so is comparatively very inconvenient.
Diablo 3 RMT Details
(link)If I no longer need an item I bought in the auction house, can I relist it in the auction house?Yes. Once you've purchased an item you can do anything with it that you could if you had acquired it through your own adventures, whether that be using it yourself, or, after a cool-down period, trading it to another character or relisting it on either the gold-based or currency-based auction house. In fact, you can generally do any combination of these things -- for example, you can purchase an item in the auction house, use it for a while, and then relist it or trade it to another character. Aside from certain quest items, there will be very few (if any) items that will be “soulbound” to your character and therefore untradable. Please note that the duration of the cool-down period mentioned above will be discussed at a later date.
Now, that is interesting! It seems this push for "more flexible business models" does finally bring along the elimination of this unimmersive 'soulbound' mechanic.
Blizzard is obviously interested in maximizing the amount of items traded and less concerned about players outfitting their characters too fast. Expect some really, really rare items ...
Ironically, these are things I have always asked for.
Seems a Devil was required to get rid of the Beelzebub :)
---
What is "smart searching"?
When players launch the auction house interface, they’ll be able to select any Diablo III character associated with their Battle.net account. The "smart search" feature will assess which item slots have available upgrades and will sort items available in the auction house based on which upgrades would be most beneficial to the character. You can also search for specific stats to match the requirements of a particular character build.
Honi soit qui mal y pense.Will buying or selling items in the auction house reveal my identity?
No. All player transactions in the gold-based and currency-based auction houses will be anonymous, and neither your real name nor your character name will be revealed to other players.
---
Thanks for the added incentive to play hardcore mode. :)If my character dies in Hardcore mode, will I lose the items that I purchased in the "Hardcore-only" gold-based auction house for that character?
Yes. Again, Hardcore-mode characters will only have access to a "Hardcore-only" gold-based auction house, not the currency-based auction house, and will not be able to trade with non-Hardcore characters. Hardcore is an optional mode designed for players who enjoy playing with the risk of permanently losing their character if the character dies, and that includes the items they acquired with that character.
Real Life Gold
The ECB will eventually have to inflate the Euro. Just like the FED is already inflating the Dollar. Of this I am (almost) certain. Therefore, I should put my money somewhere else. But where?
Gold is ridiculous right now. I mean, I sure wished I had decided to buy it a year ago. But gold is useless. It's the biggest bubble in human history. The only reason gold is valuable is because people think that it is valuable. On the other hand, in the end, that is true for almost anything.
Alternatively I could buy some Switzerland bonds. Their central bank (SNB) has just decided that a 70% overpriced currency (compared to PPP) is too much. I would agree. The Swiss are currently buying German cars and laughing at the silly amount of CHF we want in exchange. That's not funny anymore. Of course, the Switzerland export industry is laughing as well - in disbelieve. They can't believe what is happening. Nobody here can afford to buy goods from Switzerland anymore.
The SNB is really between a rock and a hard place right now. Not intervening, however, might crush their industry. So .. I can't imagine the CHF to rise even more. Not a good investment, unless you're really desperate and fear some hyperinflation.
The other strong Euro economies, like Norway or Denmark are mostly about oil. And oil prices will decline in the coming crisis - at least in the timeframe that I am talking about.
This leaves me with exotic investments like Swedish bonds of which there aren't that many or some Asian bonds of which I don't know much.
These are the times, I'd really like to save and reload. Or at least be able to make a new char ;)
Gold is ridiculous right now. I mean, I sure wished I had decided to buy it a year ago. But gold is useless. It's the biggest bubble in human history. The only reason gold is valuable is because people think that it is valuable. On the other hand, in the end, that is true for almost anything.
Alternatively I could buy some Switzerland bonds. Their central bank (SNB) has just decided that a 70% overpriced currency (compared to PPP) is too much. I would agree. The Swiss are currently buying German cars and laughing at the silly amount of CHF we want in exchange. That's not funny anymore. Of course, the Switzerland export industry is laughing as well - in disbelieve. They can't believe what is happening. Nobody here can afford to buy goods from Switzerland anymore.
The SNB is really between a rock and a hard place right now. Not intervening, however, might crush their industry. So .. I can't imagine the CHF to rise even more. Not a good investment, unless you're really desperate and fear some hyperinflation.
The other strong Euro economies, like Norway or Denmark are mostly about oil. And oil prices will decline in the coming crisis - at least in the timeframe that I am talking about.
This leaves me with exotic investments like Swedish bonds of which there aren't that many or some Asian bonds of which I don't know much.
These are the times, I'd really like to save and reload. Or at least be able to make a new char ;)
Tuesday, August 2, 2011
Leveling Game vs. Engame
This is the third post in response to the comments posted here.
Helistar encouraged me to blog on this:
Helistar wrote more than that. If you're interested, go check out his comment. On the above quote: I agree that this has happened and I agree that it is not optimal.
(1)
Let's first try to understand how it happened. MMORPGs were typically about the 'leveling game'. The designers didn't think about the endgame all that much. They didn't have much hope to keep people in the game after completing the leveling game.
However, it turned out that just attaching some PvP/PvE minigames (endgame) made players play the MMORPG for years! Woah! Nobody expected that. With WoW Blizzard focused more and more on that endgame, because it was so extraordinarily cheap to produce and kept millions of players p(l)aying.
Now, this is a working model. That's why a lot of companies clone it. The leveling game lures players into the game and the endgame keeps them paying for a game they might never have bought, if there hadn't been a leveling game.
The reason there are no pure raiding games is that raiding isn't all that interesting, really. Neither are most endgame activities. These activities are interesting mostly, because they feed on the meaning induced by the leveling game, the community and the simulation (illusion, really) of a world outside the instance.
(2)
Now, after some decade of playing these games, many gamers are bored of it. What can be done about it?
Well, if the single goal of a game is ever increasing character power, not much can be done about it. You can try to find some way to get infinite content. Like Psychochild's storybricks. But if the only goal is to increase character power, all games become boring eventually. And this does not only apply to the specific game, but all games that have character power as goal! Once you played one of them, you played them all.
Humans may be a bit stupid, but they aren't complete morons. We understand quite well that something is wrong when we hit level 77; and it doesn't feel as fun as level 5. This is especially true if all our opponents level with us.
My favorite way to solve the problem is to shift the goal of the game from character power progression (CPP), to other things. For example to defending against an ever-ongoing (and seriously dangerous) enemy undead invasion in a PvE sandbox. You can still keep a weak CPP, but you don't run out of content, if the content is created by the interaction of the players instead of an external designer.
Moreover, the goal of the game is now sustainable indefinitely. There is endless content, because it is created by the inter-player and inter-player-group relations. And we know from the real world that this is interesting for .. forever.
Helistar encouraged me to blog on this:
Several MMOs have been criticized because they turn into "two games packaged at one", i.e. the leveling game (quest-based, mostly solo) and the endgame activities (raiding/pvp), which don't share much in common.
Helistar wrote more than that. If you're interested, go check out his comment. On the above quote: I agree that this has happened and I agree that it is not optimal.
(1)
Let's first try to understand how it happened. MMORPGs were typically about the 'leveling game'. The designers didn't think about the endgame all that much. They didn't have much hope to keep people in the game after completing the leveling game.
However, it turned out that just attaching some PvP/PvE minigames (endgame) made players play the MMORPG for years! Woah! Nobody expected that. With WoW Blizzard focused more and more on that endgame, because it was so extraordinarily cheap to produce and kept millions of players p(l)aying.
Now, this is a working model. That's why a lot of companies clone it. The leveling game lures players into the game and the endgame keeps them paying for a game they might never have bought, if there hadn't been a leveling game.
The reason there are no pure raiding games is that raiding isn't all that interesting, really. Neither are most endgame activities. These activities are interesting mostly, because they feed on the meaning induced by the leveling game, the community and the simulation (illusion, really) of a world outside the instance.
(2)
Now, after some decade of playing these games, many gamers are bored of it. What can be done about it?
Well, if the single goal of a game is ever increasing character power, not much can be done about it. You can try to find some way to get infinite content. Like Psychochild's storybricks. But if the only goal is to increase character power, all games become boring eventually. And this does not only apply to the specific game, but all games that have character power as goal! Once you played one of them, you played them all.
Humans may be a bit stupid, but they aren't complete morons. We understand quite well that something is wrong when we hit level 77; and it doesn't feel as fun as level 5. This is especially true if all our opponents level with us.
My favorite way to solve the problem is to shift the goal of the game from character power progression (CPP), to other things. For example to defending against an ever-ongoing (and seriously dangerous) enemy undead invasion in a PvE sandbox. You can still keep a weak CPP, but you don't run out of content, if the content is created by the interaction of the players instead of an external designer.
Moreover, the goal of the game is now sustainable indefinitely. There is endless content, because it is created by the inter-player and inter-player-group relations. And we know from the real world that this is interesting for .. forever.
Monday, August 1, 2011
Diablo 3 RMT
After reading a few blogs on the announced D3 RMT I feel .. empty.
You might think that I hate it, but actually, no. Diablo 3 is not a virtual world. It is just a game. And apparently I can play solo and I can ignore the RMT. So .. I don't really care. Perhaps I can make a bit of money by selling stuff - probably I won't play D3 long enough for that to happen.
What's bad about this is the influence it does have on virtual worlds. But I can't imagine at that point that Titan is supposed to be a virtual world, anyway. It, too, will be just a game.
I could care less about the requirement to always be online. For me that is a holy war some people fight there. I am always online anyway. And I don't usually play games when I travel or have no access to internet.
I generally am skeptical of player-made mods. A few Elder Scrolls mods were good, but mostly I don't get much fun out of these things. To be able to change the rules of a game by downloading a mod feels wrong and arbitrary.
One last thing about the RMT AH: One big problem game companies are faced with when it comes to MT is how much each thing should cost. By having a player-run market pin-point optimal prices, they not only get the revenue-maximizing price, but also save the work to determine a good price themselves. Taking some percentage off that market-price feels better, too. And it doesn't disrupt the in-game economy.
Of course, I won't play together with anonymous players in D3, as I couldn't respect their equipment or avatar. But I never planned to play D3 multiplayer, anyway. It is just a game.
You might think that I hate it, but actually, no. Diablo 3 is not a virtual world. It is just a game. And apparently I can play solo and I can ignore the RMT. So .. I don't really care. Perhaps I can make a bit of money by selling stuff - probably I won't play D3 long enough for that to happen.
What's bad about this is the influence it does have on virtual worlds. But I can't imagine at that point that Titan is supposed to be a virtual world, anyway. It, too, will be just a game.
I could care less about the requirement to always be online. For me that is a holy war some people fight there. I am always online anyway. And I don't usually play games when I travel or have no access to internet.
I generally am skeptical of player-made mods. A few Elder Scrolls mods were good, but mostly I don't get much fun out of these things. To be able to change the rules of a game by downloading a mod feels wrong and arbitrary.
One last thing about the RMT AH: One big problem game companies are faced with when it comes to MT is how much each thing should cost. By having a player-run market pin-point optimal prices, they not only get the revenue-maximizing price, but also save the work to determine a good price themselves. Taking some percentage off that market-price feels better, too. And it doesn't disrupt the in-game economy.
Of course, I won't play together with anonymous players in D3, as I couldn't respect their equipment or avatar. But I never planned to play D3 multiplayer, anyway. It is just a game.
Trade, once again
This is the second post in response to the comments posted here.
Dàchéng encouraged me to blog on this:
(1)
The point about trade is that it is more than just the process of trading. I wrote before, in one of the posts you linked, that it is impossible to make hauling goods short-term fun for most players. Hauling goods can be safe / dangerous and short-range / long-range. That's it.
There are a few interesting decisions involved, but the real reason I want trade is not because trading is so much fun. Let's face it: For most people trading isn't as much fun as fighting anything.
I already argued that it's not a good idea to make trading any more action-oriented. My point is that trading is fun for a few people and, optimally, safe short-range trade can be relaxing for some players, just like a daily quest. Not really exciting.
The real reason I want trade is because it is fun for all non-traders. They are the majority.
(2)
Imagine a huge fantasy world. One were geography matters. No teleports, two-digit amount of hours required to go from one end to the other. Gameplay-wise each big city and its environment acts like a traditional server. But you can leave this 'server' and can go to another city. (Clarification: It's a completely open world. But most of the environment is empty of players).
The short-range trade is mostly safe, but long-range trade is dangerous for PvE and PvP reasons. Now, imagine we put some magic-deflecting material into the game. It can be mined in just one mine. What happens is this: near the mine this material is rather common and rather cheap. But in lands far away it is very expensive.
Why is this good? Because it offers diversity! The magic-deflecting material changes the balance of the entire game. Warfare between player factions is completely different near that mine than far away from it. Now imagine lots of other items that are area-specific, like that ore from the mine.
The world becomes alive! You can explore the different areas as a player and learn about them. Sure, you can also learn about them on the internet, but to experience them you need to visit these areas. Just like in any good fantasy world, materials from far away are expensive and in combination with other materials from other far places powerful.
The world becomes an interesting place. You can learn about this place. There's even different balance depending on where you are in the world! We replace some finely-tuned gameplay fun (WoW) with an interesting place to explore and interesting interactions between players in an often un-fair, unbalanced world.
(3)
This design contradicts todays industry-standard of finely-tuned gameplay loops: the idea that you first make the first 10 seconds fun, then the next 5 minutes, etc. Instead, it enthralls the players with the promise of adventure and exploration that drives them forward!
If you ask me that is what has driven players forward ever since the first leveling game. That finely-tuned gameplay isn't unimportant, either. But we all know how boring finely-tuned daily quests are!
Abstractly speaking, we don't introduce one finely-tuned pattern into the world that players can explore, but many patterns that interact and thus create new patterns. This interaction of patterns happens via the players. Thus we trade one finely-tuned pattern for many, much more interesting, patterns. This is (passively) player-generated content.
A player-run economy with trade is invaluable for this game. Not because being a trader is so much fun, but because adventuring in a world with trade and traders is so much fun.
Dàchéng encouraged me to blog on this:
I'd like to see more development of your very interesting ideas on hauling goods over trade routes. You touched on it when discussing travel here, and developed your ideas here, where I pointed out that the actual hauliers would get ganked by bandits, or bored by repetition, or both. You followed up on that here, pointing out that the repetitive nature of travelling trade-routes could be soothing rather than boring.
All the same, I think there's some fun missing, from the haulier's point of view. I understand that you may not want "action", but some other enjoyable or interesting activity has to take its place (I like your idea that just building tension can keep hauliers interested).
(1)
The point about trade is that it is more than just the process of trading. I wrote before, in one of the posts you linked, that it is impossible to make hauling goods short-term fun for most players. Hauling goods can be safe / dangerous and short-range / long-range. That's it.
There are a few interesting decisions involved, but the real reason I want trade is not because trading is so much fun. Let's face it: For most people trading isn't as much fun as fighting anything.
I already argued that it's not a good idea to make trading any more action-oriented. My point is that trading is fun for a few people and, optimally, safe short-range trade can be relaxing for some players, just like a daily quest. Not really exciting.
The real reason I want trade is because it is fun for all non-traders. They are the majority.
(2)
Imagine a huge fantasy world. One were geography matters. No teleports, two-digit amount of hours required to go from one end to the other. Gameplay-wise each big city and its environment acts like a traditional server. But you can leave this 'server' and can go to another city. (Clarification: It's a completely open world. But most of the environment is empty of players).
The short-range trade is mostly safe, but long-range trade is dangerous for PvE and PvP reasons. Now, imagine we put some magic-deflecting material into the game. It can be mined in just one mine. What happens is this: near the mine this material is rather common and rather cheap. But in lands far away it is very expensive.
Why is this good? Because it offers diversity! The magic-deflecting material changes the balance of the entire game. Warfare between player factions is completely different near that mine than far away from it. Now imagine lots of other items that are area-specific, like that ore from the mine.
The world becomes alive! You can explore the different areas as a player and learn about them. Sure, you can also learn about them on the internet, but to experience them you need to visit these areas. Just like in any good fantasy world, materials from far away are expensive and in combination with other materials from other far places powerful.
The world becomes an interesting place. You can learn about this place. There's even different balance depending on where you are in the world! We replace some finely-tuned gameplay fun (WoW) with an interesting place to explore and interesting interactions between players in an often un-fair, unbalanced world.
(3)
This design contradicts todays industry-standard of finely-tuned gameplay loops: the idea that you first make the first 10 seconds fun, then the next 5 minutes, etc. Instead, it enthralls the players with the promise of adventure and exploration that drives them forward!
If you ask me that is what has driven players forward ever since the first leveling game. That finely-tuned gameplay isn't unimportant, either. But we all know how boring finely-tuned daily quests are!
Abstractly speaking, we don't introduce one finely-tuned pattern into the world that players can explore, but many patterns that interact and thus create new patterns. This interaction of patterns happens via the players. Thus we trade one finely-tuned pattern for many, much more interesting, patterns. This is (passively) player-generated content.
A player-run economy with trade is invaluable for this game. Not because being a trader is so much fun, but because adventuring in a world with trade and traders is so much fun.
The Lesser Evil
Seems I have been wrong with my last post.
This 'compromise' is bad on almost all levels for the President. It's bad from an economic point of view and bad from a political point of view. The only thing Obama can still hope is that he's the lesser evil in the next elections. He probably is.
But that's not an achievement. You could pick any of 50% of US citizens as candidate for Presidency and he'd / she'd be the lesser evil compared to those republican candidates.
This 'compromise' is bad on almost all levels for the President. It's bad from an economic point of view and bad from a political point of view. The only thing Obama can still hope is that he's the lesser evil in the next elections. He probably is.
But that's not an achievement. You could pick any of 50% of US citizens as candidate for Presidency and he'd / she'd be the lesser evil compared to those republican candidates.
Friday, July 29, 2011
On War
I'm going to work through your comments eventually. Right now, however, I'd like to write a bit about war. More specifically, about the political war in the US.
Irrespective of your actual opinion about the debt ceiling discussion, you have to admit that the president is behaving very strangely.
1) He seems willing to make extraordinary concessions to the Tea Party that would most probably cost him the re-election.
2) He constantly talks to the public about it and gives poisoned praise to Mr. Boehner.
3) There are reasons to believe he sabotages any agreement. For example his sudden demand for $400 Billion more revenue just before they had an agreement.
4) His latest speech was highly harmful considering the actual negotiations. And it wasn't anything else!
5) "Don't call my bluff, Eric" - really ???
What the hell is going on here? Well, here's my personal opinion:
The president expertly and painfully anatomizes the Tea Party. And there's nothing they can do. Most probably they don't even see it coming.
Now, perhaps you think I have gone crazy, but look at what is actually happening! It is impossible to blame the president for not compromising enough. He successfully implemented the narrative that he would be willing to sacrifice all his party stands for to reach a deal!
And yet he does everything to sabotage a compromise. The speech this Monday .. what else did it do than sabotage? I mean, I agree with everything the president said, but the political effect of this is sabotage. And the president is not a newbie.
This is the guy who came out of nowhere and beat Hillary Clinton. He then was elected President in a landslide victory. He pushed a health care reform through and a financial reform. That is more than most presidents before him achieved - and he did it in the worst political climate .. ever?
He ordered the execution of Somali pirates in cold blood and succeeded. He ordered the expansion of one of the most powerful death-from-above programs in history in the AfPak border reagion. He ordered an attack on Libya completely circumventing Congress! Most prominently, he was shaking hands and smiling for months while preparing the execution of Osama Bin Laden at night. And he succeeded.
Some supporters think he should lead more. But that he did in the first two years (health care reform, financial reform and countless other reforms). What he does right now is using the momentum of his opponents to throw them flying through the air and on their backs. In fact, he is firing up their momentum. And, yes, this strike is going to be lethal.
Once he is re-elected, he will quietly complete his reforms (Congress blocked major parts of them).
Is he going to be successful this time? Well, I think his plan is working beyond his wildest dreams right now! And even though I mostly agree with the President's goals, I feel a shiver running over my back when I consider how effectively he eliminates his opposition.
On the debt ceiling: He will be the great Saviour when he finally cites the 14th amendment. But he will wait cold-blooded as ever for the perfect moment to do this.
Irrespective of your actual opinion about the debt ceiling discussion, you have to admit that the president is behaving very strangely.
1) He seems willing to make extraordinary concessions to the Tea Party that would most probably cost him the re-election.
2) He constantly talks to the public about it and gives poisoned praise to Mr. Boehner.
3) There are reasons to believe he sabotages any agreement. For example his sudden demand for $400 Billion more revenue just before they had an agreement.
4) His latest speech was highly harmful considering the actual negotiations. And it wasn't anything else!
5) "Don't call my bluff, Eric" - really ???
What the hell is going on here? Well, here's my personal opinion:
The president expertly and painfully anatomizes the Tea Party. And there's nothing they can do. Most probably they don't even see it coming.
Now, perhaps you think I have gone crazy, but look at what is actually happening! It is impossible to blame the president for not compromising enough. He successfully implemented the narrative that he would be willing to sacrifice all his party stands for to reach a deal!
And yet he does everything to sabotage a compromise. The speech this Monday .. what else did it do than sabotage? I mean, I agree with everything the president said, but the political effect of this is sabotage. And the president is not a newbie.
This is the guy who came out of nowhere and beat Hillary Clinton. He then was elected President in a landslide victory. He pushed a health care reform through and a financial reform. That is more than most presidents before him achieved - and he did it in the worst political climate .. ever?
He ordered the execution of Somali pirates in cold blood and succeeded. He ordered the expansion of one of the most powerful death-from-above programs in history in the AfPak border reagion. He ordered an attack on Libya completely circumventing Congress! Most prominently, he was shaking hands and smiling for months while preparing the execution of Osama Bin Laden at night. And he succeeded.
Some supporters think he should lead more. But that he did in the first two years (health care reform, financial reform and countless other reforms). What he does right now is using the momentum of his opponents to throw them flying through the air and on their backs. In fact, he is firing up their momentum. And, yes, this strike is going to be lethal.
Once he is re-elected, he will quietly complete his reforms (Congress blocked major parts of them).
Is he going to be successful this time? Well, I think his plan is working beyond his wildest dreams right now! And even though I mostly agree with the President's goals, I feel a shiver running over my back when I consider how effectively he eliminates his opposition.
On the debt ceiling: He will be the great Saviour when he finally cites the 14th amendment. But he will wait cold-blooded as ever for the perfect moment to do this.
Thursday, July 28, 2011
Player Impact on Game Design
This is the first post in response to the comments posted here.
Syl encouraged me to blog on this:
In my opinion player power, when it comes to the design process, is detrimental to the quality of the game. Optimally a MMORPG is designed by one or two masterminds. Two only if they can argue without offending each other - ever. No three-man constellation is ever stable and more masterminds mean too many bad compromises.
The masterminds need to have the entire game design (the big! picture) in their head at all times. They need to share a vision for the game that extends beyond "getting rich". They should be supported by a diverse council of at least five professionals who care enough to argue with them without having any authority / responsibility. The coucil should meet regularily and the masterminds should be required to defend their design decisions in front of the council.
The only way players should influence the game on a game design level is via professional community managers, whose job is to report the status of the community to the masterminds/council. When it comes to forums, I absolutely agree with Elder Game.
The feedback part of the community managers' task is twofold:
1) Gather the few brilliant posts on the forum, anonymize them, and pass them on. Passed on posts should be marked to incentivise thoughtful and concise posts.
2) Help with interpreting statistics.
Optimally, the players consider the developers to be 100% non-responding to player demands. Once players feel they can have an impact, they start to play the developers instead of playing the game. This is harmful for the game and - more importantly - it diminishes the players' fun.
Player impact should always be indirect; via the community managers or via statistics. It is very important that the masterminds know how to interpret statistics. If necessary they should be supported by a professional statistician.
Statistics should be used to refine and realize the original vision, not to increase the cash flow. The reason is that refining and realizing the original vision is the best approach to making lots of money. Whereas making lots of money as a goal, turns out to be bad at making lots of money. Obliquity.
I am not a supporter of Eve's CSM. It is a poor man's community management.
Syl encouraged me to blog on this:
- player power vs. dev power. how big should each be, what's the correct balance, when are they too high? Or: when is player impact still positive, when does it become negative / where should devs keep the ultimate say.
In my opinion player power, when it comes to the design process, is detrimental to the quality of the game. Optimally a MMORPG is designed by one or two masterminds. Two only if they can argue without offending each other - ever. No three-man constellation is ever stable and more masterminds mean too many bad compromises.
The masterminds need to have the entire game design (the big! picture) in their head at all times. They need to share a vision for the game that extends beyond "getting rich". They should be supported by a diverse council of at least five professionals who care enough to argue with them without having any authority / responsibility. The coucil should meet regularily and the masterminds should be required to defend their design decisions in front of the council.
The only way players should influence the game on a game design level is via professional community managers, whose job is to report the status of the community to the masterminds/council. When it comes to forums, I absolutely agree with Elder Game.
The feedback part of the community managers' task is twofold:
1) Gather the few brilliant posts on the forum, anonymize them, and pass them on. Passed on posts should be marked to incentivise thoughtful and concise posts.
2) Help with interpreting statistics.
Optimally, the players consider the developers to be 100% non-responding to player demands. Once players feel they can have an impact, they start to play the developers instead of playing the game. This is harmful for the game and - more importantly - it diminishes the players' fun.
Player impact should always be indirect; via the community managers or via statistics. It is very important that the masterminds know how to interpret statistics. If necessary they should be supported by a professional statistician.
Statistics should be used to refine and realize the original vision, not to increase the cash flow. The reason is that refining and realizing the original vision is the best approach to making lots of money. Whereas making lots of money as a goal, turns out to be bad at making lots of money. Obliquity.
I am not a supporter of Eve's CSM. It is a poor man's community management.
Wednesday, July 27, 2011
Ask me
Some readers sent me emails and a few others commented on the last post that they would love me to write a bit more about MMO design again. Well, so would I. The problem is that I have only very abstract things to blog about. I don't play any MMORPG seriously for half a year now.
So, I decided to give you the chance to suggest topics. In the comments of this post you can leave questions and topic suggestions. Anything you want me to write about. There's no guarantee, obviously, but I'll try to write a post on what you suggest.
Make sure that you make the topic/question look interesting, please. Also, I have no desire to repeat some of the too frequent topics of the MMORPG blogosphere.
So, I decided to give you the chance to suggest topics. In the comments of this post you can leave questions and topic suggestions. Anything you want me to write about. There's no guarantee, obviously, but I'll try to write a post on what you suggest.
Make sure that you make the topic/question look interesting, please. Also, I have no desire to repeat some of the too frequent topics of the MMORPG blogosphere.
Tuesday, July 26, 2011
This makes sense to me
This makes sense to me; mostly. I don't buy the "we should spend more to reduce the deficit"-notion and I think the interviewers are too opinonated. But what is said by Mr. Stiglitz sounds mostly plausible to me.
But I'm sure there are some nobel prize winning economists, who say the opposite. If somebody got a link, I'd love to watch/read.
Interview starts at 13:00
The article in question.
But I'm sure there are some nobel prize winning economists, who say the opposite. If somebody got a link, I'd love to watch/read.
Interview starts at 13:00
The article in question.
Monday, July 25, 2011
Dualisms
Humanity is all about dualisms. Almost every activity has its own. In politics there is Left and Right. In MMORPGs there is Themepark vs Sandbox, game vs. world, casual vs. hardcore.
What's interesting is that there is a high correlation between themepark/game/casual and sandbox/world/hardcore. Without much reason. The same is true in politics. There is a high correlation between pro-nuclear energy, contra-abortion and small government. Without much reason it seems.
The reason is evolution. In the 10.000 tribes scenario I described a few days ago, the best way to solve complicated problems was try & error. That's why humans tend towards one side of a dualism and band together. The opinion becomes an ideology when people have a strong initial reaction towards something.
Remember that NYT article ?
I'm not giving you the link, because I don't want you to read it. Fact is that most of you have a strong initial emotional reaction once you read this. Only after that initial emotional reaction will you start to try to find arguments for or against it.
In the 10.000 tribes scenario this is a powerful evolutionary mechanic. The tribe becomes ideological about the most important questions and eventually splits. Since the tribe must not split into too many parts, groups converge. Thus, the guy who believes in global warming suddenly also believes in higher taxes. What is important to realize is that this convergence is (mostly) arbitrary, completely subtle and unconscious.
Of course, nowadays we cannot realistically split, let alone wage planet-destroying world wars. So we need to compromise eternally. Modern societies are all about this eternal compromising.
If you want to reach beyond your "ape instincts" as the lovely ideologist Gevlon so fittingly calls it, you need to try to ignore the first initial reaction. You need to look at the arguments first and only then form your opinion. Of course, you will fail; you're human. All you can do is be aware of this effect.
What's interesting is that there is a high correlation between themepark/game/casual and sandbox/world/hardcore. Without much reason. The same is true in politics. There is a high correlation between pro-nuclear energy, contra-abortion and small government. Without much reason it seems.
The reason is evolution. In the 10.000 tribes scenario I described a few days ago, the best way to solve complicated problems was try & error. That's why humans tend towards one side of a dualism and band together. The opinion becomes an ideology when people have a strong initial reaction towards something.
Remember that NYT article ?
Subsidize Vegetables
We could save billions in health care costs and make healthier food cheaper if we taxed nutritionally weak foods.
I'm not giving you the link, because I don't want you to read it. Fact is that most of you have a strong initial emotional reaction once you read this. Only after that initial emotional reaction will you start to try to find arguments for or against it.
In the 10.000 tribes scenario this is a powerful evolutionary mechanic. The tribe becomes ideological about the most important questions and eventually splits. Since the tribe must not split into too many parts, groups converge. Thus, the guy who believes in global warming suddenly also believes in higher taxes. What is important to realize is that this convergence is (mostly) arbitrary, completely subtle and unconscious.
Of course, nowadays we cannot realistically split, let alone wage planet-destroying world wars. So we need to compromise eternally. Modern societies are all about this eternal compromising.
If you want to reach beyond your "ape instincts" as the lovely ideologist Gevlon so fittingly calls it, you need to try to ignore the first initial reaction. You need to look at the arguments first and only then form your opinion. Of course, you will fail; you're human. All you can do is be aware of this effect.
Sunday, July 24, 2011
Right and Left: Differences
Now, this might be a bit contentious. But here's my hypothesis.
The Right
The Right tries to achieve a god-given basic state, often described with 'freedom' and 'liberty'. It thinks that the less government there is, the better. But the point here is that this is not a conclusion. It is the thesis, or even the axiom. The Right may argue that 'free markets' are useful, but that is not why the Right desires them. The god-given basic state of humanity, the cowboy on his ranch, is the goal the Right wants to achieve.
Of course, the Right is often right (no pun intended), when it comes to the benefit of little government influence, the invisible hand and the pure power a free market can unleash when it comes to generation of wealth. But this just strengthens the arguement for the god-given state. It is not the reason for this desire.
The Left
The Left tries to achieve a human-created state. A state that allows everybody to live a life free of misery. They are willing to use any means necessary to achieve this. If big government is necessary, then so be it.
Of course, the Left knows that free markets are incredibly powerful at creation of wealth, and it often argues in favor of them. But free markets are just a tool the Left begrudgingly uses to increase the size of the cake it ultimately wants to redistribute.
Both
Both are extreme ideologies, of course. The Failure of the Right often is that it doesn't want to create a society anybody actually would want to live in, but rather a visionary god-given state that in its truest form is probably not desirable for most people. The Failure of the Left is that it overestimates the human ability to govern itself and ignores harmful side effects of laws and centralization.
Example
In todays NYT I found this:
Now, this proposal is obviously on the left hand side of the political spectrum. The Right will disagree with this, and it will give all kinds of arguments. But the real reason the Right disagrees is that such a tax would remove the country from the god-given state.
The Left, on the other hand, welcomes such a proposal. It is always looking for easy ways to make life better. There might be negative side effects of such a new tax, but it's something the Left would have a look at before it would discard the proposal.
The Right
The Right tries to achieve a god-given basic state, often described with 'freedom' and 'liberty'. It thinks that the less government there is, the better. But the point here is that this is not a conclusion. It is the thesis, or even the axiom. The Right may argue that 'free markets' are useful, but that is not why the Right desires them. The god-given basic state of humanity, the cowboy on his ranch, is the goal the Right wants to achieve.
Of course, the Right is often right (no pun intended), when it comes to the benefit of little government influence, the invisible hand and the pure power a free market can unleash when it comes to generation of wealth. But this just strengthens the arguement for the god-given state. It is not the reason for this desire.
The Left
The Left tries to achieve a human-created state. A state that allows everybody to live a life free of misery. They are willing to use any means necessary to achieve this. If big government is necessary, then so be it.
Of course, the Left knows that free markets are incredibly powerful at creation of wealth, and it often argues in favor of them. But free markets are just a tool the Left begrudgingly uses to increase the size of the cake it ultimately wants to redistribute.
Both
Both are extreme ideologies, of course. The Failure of the Right often is that it doesn't want to create a society anybody actually would want to live in, but rather a visionary god-given state that in its truest form is probably not desirable for most people. The Failure of the Left is that it overestimates the human ability to govern itself and ignores harmful side effects of laws and centralization.
Example
In todays NYT I found this:
Subsidize Vegetables
We could save billions in health care costs and make healthier food cheaper if we taxed nutritionally weak foods.
Now, this proposal is obviously on the left hand side of the political spectrum. The Right will disagree with this, and it will give all kinds of arguments. But the real reason the Right disagrees is that such a tax would remove the country from the god-given state.
The Left, on the other hand, welcomes such a proposal. It is always looking for easy ways to make life better. There might be negative side effects of such a new tax, but it's something the Left would have a look at before it would discard the proposal.
Giannis' comment
Giannis made an interesting comment earlier today. It's great to have a Greek actually share his opinion, I think. I'll get at the comment paragraph for paragraph.
Germany, actually has a little more debt than Italy in absolute terms, but there are more Germans and on average they produce more valuable goods/services. Thus, Germany is probably not going to default anytime soon. Another reason is that, in a shared effort, Germany's parties put a paragraph into the constitution a few years ago that demands a balanced budget. And so far all parties seem very serious about it.
Let's assume you do a revolution and throw your politicians out of the country. .. Then what? Will the new politicians be better? Why?
Nils I just wanted to make clear that is not Greece that are saved but the big banks of europe and the whole Europe..because of what you said..I think both are saved. If all banks defaulted, Greece wouldn't be in good shape, either. In fact, there would probably be a civil war for power and food. If you think the current economic crisis is bad, what do you think it will be like when nobody can get any more money from the banks, and the money runs out, and the food runs out, because nobody has an incentive to import food anymore?
After Greece would be Portugal and then Spain and then Italy, it would start a domino of bankrupt..
Although as Greek I want to inform you and your readers,in case they don't know, that Greek people have the lowest wages by far in europe..all the money greece is missing are stolen money from illegal business our politicians had with corporations.Nobody questions that many Greek politicians, and bureaucrats are corrupt. But that's really the Greeks' fault. I can't do much about it when they elect the wrong guys again and again for decades.
In conclusion Greece has one of the lowest debts in Europe..Italy have a Debt almost ten times more than Greece. The reason they attacked Greece is that our politicians "wanted to be attacked" and they managed to succeed this with purpose.Erm, you need to look at debt per GDP. It makes no sense to look at absolute debt. Italy is the third biggest economy of the Euro zone, of course they have more debt. They have more people and these people, on average, produce more valuable goods/services.Thus they have an easier time repaying the debt.
Germany, actually has a little more debt than Italy in absolute terms, but there are more Germans and on average they produce more valuable goods/services. Thus, Germany is probably not going to default anytime soon. Another reason is that, in a shared effort, Germany's parties put a paragraph into the constitution a few years ago that demands a balanced budget. And so far all parties seem very serious about it.
The reason is that if our people is fall to unemployment and hungry, they can do some things without having opposition..they want to sell greece in the 1/100 of the real price and to show us this as a solution to our problems..I think that is a conspiracy theory of yours. I don't think it is possible to plan something like this, even if a majority of the politicians wanted to.
Nevermind, my purpose wasn't to offend you, if you watched the news you would see million greeks on the streets trying to throw away of the country the thiefs politicians. And the Eyrope know very well that they are thiefs, but as I said they do business with them, they sell submarines, airplanes, e.t.c.I saw that and I symphatize. But what next? If the Greek people presented to the EU a new government + bureaucracy with new and trustworthy people that are not going to waste our money, the EU would love to help you with the revolution. I'd go on the streets for that here in Germany. The problem is that you don't have an alternative.
Let's assume you do a revolution and throw your politicians out of the country. .. Then what? Will the new politicians be better? Why?
Azuriel's comment
This is a wonderful comment by Azuriel.
It is wonderful, because it so clearly shows the problem. When I read this comment my blood pressure raises by a few percent (maybe more) and I repeat this question in my head "How is it that he doesn't understand?".
But the first thing I have to accept is that Azuriel is actually serious. And he is not alone. During my MMORPG discussions I met hundreds of people 'like Azuriel'. It took me a long time before I accepted that they were not mocking me.
Of course, on this blog I explained a few dozen times already what I mean when I say immersion and credibility and consistency. But let's do it again.
First, I do not want a realistic game. Realistic games are boring. I already 'play' one in real life.
What I do want is a simulation of a fantasy world that employs good gameplay and occasionally compromises between gameplay, simulation and a few other things.
For example, shitting improves the simulation a tiny bit, adds nothing to gameplay and insults my good taste. I don't want it. Nor do I want 'realistic' death effects. They, too, would be good simulation, but I don't want to see enemies suffer while they bleed to death.
The most prominent fantasy world was designed by J. R. R. Tolkien. He spent many years of his life making sure that Middle Earth world was consistent. For example, some people could cast magic, but others couldn't. Teleporting wasn't possible.
Now, if you make a computer game in this fantasy world, I would like it to be as consistent as possible. I want magic to be in there, because that's part of Middle Earth. But I don't want teleports to be in there, because that's not consistent with the simulation.
Of course, you can decide to simulate a different fantasy world. In WoW lore there are lots of portals and, thus, teleporting via portal is ok from a simulation point of view. I think it's often wrong from a gameplay PoV, but that's off topic. What's not good is if I can teleport in WoW without actually using a portal. That's not even consistent with the World of Warcraft.
Now, sometimes there are good reasons why computer game simulations of a fantasy world cannot be consistent. For example, fire in middle earth is supposed to incinerate wood. But that's technically impossible to implement. Therefore, I don't complain about it. I sure wish that this technical limitation is some day overcome, but right now I just suspend disbelieve.
It's different when it comes to things like teleports or resilience or lots of other stuff that is not consistent with the simulation. Sometimes I agree that the gameplay is more important than the simulation - but sometimes I think that the potential gains in gameplay do not outweigh the loss of quality of the simulation. And quality of the simulation is what I need to immerse myself into the world.
And once again, because that is Psychochild's favourite argument :)
The fact that a simulation isn't perfect in the first place, is not a good argument to make it even worse.
At some level everybody values the simulation aspect, of course. Otherwise there would be no need for good graphics.
I honestly don't get this "immersion" argument you are making. Having a backpack based on weight is less immersive than magic in the fantasy genre you love? You realize dragon's couldn't fly based on their weight and bone structure, right? It is almost as though you don't actually want to be playing a videogame at all - you want a simulation, not something designed to be entertaining and not cumbersome.
Maybe you should just take up hiking and camping IRL, eh?
In Fallout 3 and NV, even though it was not required, I got so into the narrative that I explored every single nook and cranny of every structure for usable items despite having more bullets/caps than I could ever actually use. Scavenging itself was fun, as was trying to steal everything in the house/shop without getting caught. It did not break immersion to me that I was lugging around 250 lbs of gear because of a little thing called "suspension of disbelief." If I could only carry maybe 2 gallons of water (16 lbs), two guns, a handful of ammo, etc, the literal gameplay would be boring and masochistic.
I mean, when was the last time you read a fantasy novel when they talked about the main character taking a shit? That presumably happens every 1-2 days in the story, but the author leaves it out. Immersion break, amirite? I just don't get how and why you draw lines when you do.
It is wonderful, because it so clearly shows the problem. When I read this comment my blood pressure raises by a few percent (maybe more) and I repeat this question in my head "How is it that he doesn't understand?".
But the first thing I have to accept is that Azuriel is actually serious. And he is not alone. During my MMORPG discussions I met hundreds of people 'like Azuriel'. It took me a long time before I accepted that they were not mocking me.
Of course, on this blog I explained a few dozen times already what I mean when I say immersion and credibility and consistency. But let's do it again.
First, I do not want a realistic game. Realistic games are boring. I already 'play' one in real life.
What I do want is a simulation of a fantasy world that employs good gameplay and occasionally compromises between gameplay, simulation and a few other things.
For example, shitting improves the simulation a tiny bit, adds nothing to gameplay and insults my good taste. I don't want it. Nor do I want 'realistic' death effects. They, too, would be good simulation, but I don't want to see enemies suffer while they bleed to death.
The most prominent fantasy world was designed by J. R. R. Tolkien. He spent many years of his life making sure that Middle Earth world was consistent. For example, some people could cast magic, but others couldn't. Teleporting wasn't possible.
Now, if you make a computer game in this fantasy world, I would like it to be as consistent as possible. I want magic to be in there, because that's part of Middle Earth. But I don't want teleports to be in there, because that's not consistent with the simulation.
Of course, you can decide to simulate a different fantasy world. In WoW lore there are lots of portals and, thus, teleporting via portal is ok from a simulation point of view. I think it's often wrong from a gameplay PoV, but that's off topic. What's not good is if I can teleport in WoW without actually using a portal. That's not even consistent with the World of Warcraft.
Now, sometimes there are good reasons why computer game simulations of a fantasy world cannot be consistent. For example, fire in middle earth is supposed to incinerate wood. But that's technically impossible to implement. Therefore, I don't complain about it. I sure wish that this technical limitation is some day overcome, but right now I just suspend disbelieve.
It's different when it comes to things like teleports or resilience or lots of other stuff that is not consistent with the simulation. Sometimes I agree that the gameplay is more important than the simulation - but sometimes I think that the potential gains in gameplay do not outweigh the loss of quality of the simulation. And quality of the simulation is what I need to immerse myself into the world.
And once again, because that is Psychochild's favourite argument :)
The fact that a simulation isn't perfect in the first place, is not a good argument to make it even worse.
At some level everybody values the simulation aspect, of course. Otherwise there would be no need for good graphics.
Saturday, July 23, 2011
Not Understanding Frightens Me
(Link)
I seriously disagree with President Obama when it comes to civil liberties. I do disagree when it comes to Afghanistan. I don't think the process of going to war with Libya was flattering.
However, the left wing blogs I read are on fire with what the President was offering the other side on a silver plate. So he is right: He is willing to take a lot of heat. In fact, should the Republicans have agreed, there's a good chance this compromise would have made him a one-term president. You know, he has no spine and stuff like that.
So, what is the Right thinking? Do they want to bluff until the very, very last minute? When is the very, very last minute?
Comparing this to EU politics is frustrating and funny at the same time. EU politics are difficult to understand, but everyone is willing to compromise. We just got a compromise that included 17 countries, the ECB and the IMF. Most of the leaders of these countries are taking a lot of heat over what they agreed to.
US politics, on the other hand, are trivial to understand. But the two parties are unable to compromise. And while I would very much like to appear bi-partisan, it is very, very hard to argue that the responsibility for that is with both parties.
So what will happen? Well, the US is not going to default anytime soon. If in doubt the president will argue along the 14th amendment, just like President Clinton already proposed.
The real problem is not this deficit talk. Should some rating agencies, let alone all of them, downgrade US debt, a lot of institutional investors will have to get out of US papers. That might very well start an avalanche. But it probably would not.
The real problem is that US is unable to compromise for the foreseeable future. Just like California, whole US is paralyzed. And borrowing 40 cent of every dollar is already the worst deficit in the developed world, by far. I argued before, in my parable, that the US interest rates will remain low for an extraordinary amount of time. And then, suddenly, they will spike into the sky. It will be swift, but the aftermath will not be painless.
The story becomes really twisted when you think of Euro bonds. The reason most investors bet on US papers is that there is no alternative. It's a ponzi scheme: Investors do not buy 15-year US papers, because they think that they will get back the money from the US, but because they think that other investors think, that other investors think (insert loop), that these papers can be sold to other investors.
Should the EU (have to) introduce Euro-bonds there will be a sudden alternative. The Euro is already 20% more expensive than it should be from a PPP point of view. It's a bit crazy, but the EU's strength could be the trigger for the US's sudden decline. And, of course, that decline would devastate the EU as well, and the rest of the world, including China. Add some Saudi vs Iran war with frightended Israel in the center of it and remember Pakistani nuclear weapons in terrorists' hands. I'm not a pessimist - I just like to think this chain reaction through ..
What will happen? Nothing during the next few months or years. Eventually, however, FED and ECB will start printing money like mad, because that is the only way out of this mess. The last time problems of that scale were solved with inflation, we got a world war. Not solving this with inflation isn't a solution, either. The only thing I can guarantee you is that we won't get a world war. We'd rather get a decade of economic decline, hunger, misery and civil wars.
Anyway, I should remain careful with predictions, because I still don't understand the Republicans' grand plan. I hope there is one ...
I seriously disagree with President Obama when it comes to civil liberties. I do disagree when it comes to Afghanistan. I don't think the process of going to war with Libya was flattering.
However, the left wing blogs I read are on fire with what the President was offering the other side on a silver plate. So he is right: He is willing to take a lot of heat. In fact, should the Republicans have agreed, there's a good chance this compromise would have made him a one-term president. You know, he has no spine and stuff like that.
So, what is the Right thinking? Do they want to bluff until the very, very last minute? When is the very, very last minute?
Comparing this to EU politics is frustrating and funny at the same time. EU politics are difficult to understand, but everyone is willing to compromise. We just got a compromise that included 17 countries, the ECB and the IMF. Most of the leaders of these countries are taking a lot of heat over what they agreed to.
US politics, on the other hand, are trivial to understand. But the two parties are unable to compromise. And while I would very much like to appear bi-partisan, it is very, very hard to argue that the responsibility for that is with both parties.
So what will happen? Well, the US is not going to default anytime soon. If in doubt the president will argue along the 14th amendment, just like President Clinton already proposed.
The real problem is not this deficit talk. Should some rating agencies, let alone all of them, downgrade US debt, a lot of institutional investors will have to get out of US papers. That might very well start an avalanche. But it probably would not.
The real problem is that US is unable to compromise for the foreseeable future. Just like California, whole US is paralyzed. And borrowing 40 cent of every dollar is already the worst deficit in the developed world, by far. I argued before, in my parable, that the US interest rates will remain low for an extraordinary amount of time. And then, suddenly, they will spike into the sky. It will be swift, but the aftermath will not be painless.
The story becomes really twisted when you think of Euro bonds. The reason most investors bet on US papers is that there is no alternative. It's a ponzi scheme: Investors do not buy 15-year US papers, because they think that they will get back the money from the US, but because they think that other investors think, that other investors think (insert loop), that these papers can be sold to other investors.
Should the EU (have to) introduce Euro-bonds there will be a sudden alternative. The Euro is already 20% more expensive than it should be from a PPP point of view. It's a bit crazy, but the EU's strength could be the trigger for the US's sudden decline. And, of course, that decline would devastate the EU as well, and the rest of the world, including China. Add some Saudi vs Iran war with frightended Israel in the center of it and remember Pakistani nuclear weapons in terrorists' hands. I'm not a pessimist - I just like to think this chain reaction through ..
What will happen? Nothing during the next few months or years. Eventually, however, FED and ECB will start printing money like mad, because that is the only way out of this mess. The last time problems of that scale were solved with inflation, we got a world war. Not solving this with inflation isn't a solution, either. The only thing I can guarantee you is that we won't get a world war. We'd rather get a decade of economic decline, hunger, misery and civil wars.
Anyway, I should remain careful with predictions, because I still don't understand the Republicans' grand plan. I hope there is one ...
Friday, July 22, 2011
Spending my Time
Not playing any MMORPG leaves a big hole in your time management. For a while I was able to fill it with all those things I've always wanted to do. Then I had lots of visits going on. Finally I watched Game of Thrones, but that was over in about 10 hours. Then I played Crysis 2. It took 12 hours. I don't even want to know how long it takes at easy difficulty.
And now, this morning, I was scanning through those games I have installed.
Fallout New Vegas. Mmh, the character control is terrible. Higher difficulties make the enemies immortal instead of the game more difficult. Very easy to optimize the fun out of it. I started it nonetheless.
I am in the doctor's house. He tells me all kinds of stuff. I try to take some of his things. He looks at me and .. nothing. I rob the entire fucking house. He doesn't care. Ragequit.
Mass Effect 2. This endless intro cannot be skipped. sigh. The gameplay is fun, but the story is so damn boring, because I already played through it !! Then I need to scan planets for metals. After 5 minutes I quit. If I could just play the game instead of following the 08-15 story and farming minerals I probably don't even need, it might be fun.
Minecraft. Lovely Minecraft. If only my creations had any meaning. If only the combat would be more than completely rudimentary. I think I'll wait for the next adventure patch.
Neverwinter Nights 2. Always trouble to get used to the interface again. But the character creation is so much fun. To read through all the gods and religions. I could do that forever. I do do that for forever! Then I start the game. Next I have to take that stupid dwarf with me. HEY! hello? I don't want him! I am perfectly able to beat every enemy on my own. At hardest difficulty. Sigh. I suck it up. Eventually I get more and more companions. Suddenly I have to leave some of them behind. Why? For gameplay reasons? Stupid game design! Oh, did I mention that I know the story?
Rift. puhhh.. see Wow.
Risen. That could be nice. I haven't played through the warrior part of the game yet. I bet it works the same way the mage story worked, but who knows? I remember those stupid portals in the end and how the last 20% of the game were so very terrible. But, hey, I might try Risen tomorrow.
Civilization V! Now that is a game. Just a game. I have played so many Civ V games by now that it's all a bit too boring, however. I already know that I will hate that slowing the game down will also slow my unit creation down. So, instead of being able to do more each era, I will have to press 'next turn' 30 times instead of 10 times in a row. Oh, and what is the automated micromanagement for? In the end, those enemies will either cheat me to death or I will destroy them. Civ V is good. But the AI is so damn terrible.
Starcraft II. I remember that stupid stupid story that was told even more stupidly. If I went multiplayer it would all be about execution and speed. But I would like to have fun watching my units and stuff. Speed and RTS doesn't work for me. And it's meaningless, anyway: a game ends and is forgotten after a few hours max.
Witcher 2. If I could only crawl through the few dungeons for more than a few minutes. But I would have to play through the story. Which I know from every perspective, because stupid me read through that little book that came with the box. How could I know that the entire story would be in there? Damn. Too story-focused to be re-playable anyway.
Two Worlds II. Now, last time I looked at it, I quit after I watched the character models. My main character looks to bad that I couldn't make myself play. Also, the story seemed too be so boring. Maybe I'll play it tomorrow.
World of Tanks. Oh no, I still have this on my computer? Tanks are boring. And driving around, firing at everything you see, only to be destroyed by gold ammunition or some tanks that don't even take damage and are 3x as fast? And for what?
World of Warcraft. Yeah, it's still installed. Let's imagine I resubscribed. I could run with my druid tank through daily dungeons until he is equipped. That would be a major time investment to get some +15% stats. Then what? Raiding, killing some sorry creatures, that are 100x as large as I am, in a scripted way? No thanks.
I could make a new char. I could try to read every quest and die of boredom while the mobs die from me looking at them. Or I could try to do only orange quests. What a grind to do meaningless orange quests that I couldn't care less about, because I am skipping the story! Even if I did this, I could then either die 1000x times in BGs while I farm my equip. Or I could wait 30 minutes for 20 minutes of LFD 'fun', and gain meaningless equip to .. raid. No thanks.
Dungeons of Dredmor. I bought it just recently on Steam. Let's try to ignore the graphics and immerse into the fantasy world ... ... what fantasy world? DoDr is just a joke. A big joke. Everything about it is sooo funny.
How can I immerse myself into a fantasy world that doesn't take itself seriously? How can I pray to survive the next mob if the mob is meant to be silly? 4.50 € wasted.
I did play two rounds of good old Windows Chess Titans. First I won, then I increased the difficulty and lost. Not that it meant anything to me.
I did a search for another good fantasy miniseries. Nothing.
Now I just ordered all ten "Malazan Book of the Fallen". I guess reading fantasy is what it has to be right now.
And now, this morning, I was scanning through those games I have installed.
Fallout New Vegas. Mmh, the character control is terrible. Higher difficulties make the enemies immortal instead of the game more difficult. Very easy to optimize the fun out of it. I started it nonetheless.
I am in the doctor's house. He tells me all kinds of stuff. I try to take some of his things. He looks at me and .. nothing. I rob the entire fucking house. He doesn't care. Ragequit.
Mass Effect 2. This endless intro cannot be skipped. sigh. The gameplay is fun, but the story is so damn boring, because I already played through it !! Then I need to scan planets for metals. After 5 minutes I quit. If I could just play the game instead of following the 08-15 story and farming minerals I probably don't even need, it might be fun.
Minecraft. Lovely Minecraft. If only my creations had any meaning. If only the combat would be more than completely rudimentary. I think I'll wait for the next adventure patch.
Neverwinter Nights 2. Always trouble to get used to the interface again. But the character creation is so much fun. To read through all the gods and religions. I could do that forever. I do do that for forever! Then I start the game. Next I have to take that stupid dwarf with me. HEY! hello? I don't want him! I am perfectly able to beat every enemy on my own. At hardest difficulty. Sigh. I suck it up. Eventually I get more and more companions. Suddenly I have to leave some of them behind. Why? For gameplay reasons? Stupid game design! Oh, did I mention that I know the story?
Rift. puhhh.. see Wow.
Risen. That could be nice. I haven't played through the warrior part of the game yet. I bet it works the same way the mage story worked, but who knows? I remember those stupid portals in the end and how the last 20% of the game were so very terrible. But, hey, I might try Risen tomorrow.
Civilization V! Now that is a game. Just a game. I have played so many Civ V games by now that it's all a bit too boring, however. I already know that I will hate that slowing the game down will also slow my unit creation down. So, instead of being able to do more each era, I will have to press 'next turn' 30 times instead of 10 times in a row. Oh, and what is the automated micromanagement for? In the end, those enemies will either cheat me to death or I will destroy them. Civ V is good. But the AI is so damn terrible.
Starcraft II. I remember that stupid stupid story that was told even more stupidly. If I went multiplayer it would all be about execution and speed. But I would like to have fun watching my units and stuff. Speed and RTS doesn't work for me. And it's meaningless, anyway: a game ends and is forgotten after a few hours max.
Witcher 2. If I could only crawl through the few dungeons for more than a few minutes. But I would have to play through the story. Which I know from every perspective, because stupid me read through that little book that came with the box. How could I know that the entire story would be in there? Damn. Too story-focused to be re-playable anyway.
Two Worlds II. Now, last time I looked at it, I quit after I watched the character models. My main character looks to bad that I couldn't make myself play. Also, the story seemed too be so boring. Maybe I'll play it tomorrow.
World of Tanks. Oh no, I still have this on my computer? Tanks are boring. And driving around, firing at everything you see, only to be destroyed by gold ammunition or some tanks that don't even take damage and are 3x as fast? And for what?
World of Warcraft. Yeah, it's still installed. Let's imagine I resubscribed. I could run with my druid tank through daily dungeons until he is equipped. That would be a major time investment to get some +15% stats. Then what? Raiding, killing some sorry creatures, that are 100x as large as I am, in a scripted way? No thanks.
I could make a new char. I could try to read every quest and die of boredom while the mobs die from me looking at them. Or I could try to do only orange quests. What a grind to do meaningless orange quests that I couldn't care less about, because I am skipping the story! Even if I did this, I could then either die 1000x times in BGs while I farm my equip. Or I could wait 30 minutes for 20 minutes of LFD 'fun', and gain meaningless equip to .. raid. No thanks.
Dungeons of Dredmor. I bought it just recently on Steam. Let's try to ignore the graphics and immerse into the fantasy world ... ... what fantasy world? DoDr is just a joke. A big joke. Everything about it is sooo funny.
How can I immerse myself into a fantasy world that doesn't take itself seriously? How can I pray to survive the next mob if the mob is meant to be silly? 4.50 € wasted.
I did play two rounds of good old Windows Chess Titans. First I won, then I increased the difficulty and lost. Not that it meant anything to me.
I did a search for another good fantasy miniseries. Nothing.
Now I just ordered all ten "Malazan Book of the Fallen". I guess reading fantasy is what it has to be right now.
Saving Greece .. again
Yesterday evening all 17 Euro member states agreed upon a package to save Greece. And this package once again succeeded at buying time with money. My money. It is estimated that the Greece bailout will cost Germany up to 70 billions. Considering the population of about 80 mio (including all babies, ..) that's about 875 €, or $1261 for me. Add interest and receive pure fun.
Will it help? Well, yes, for a while. Apparently the euro members want to optimize governance in October. I guess that's something.
Actually, if somebody asked me how much I, personally, was willing to pay for the existence of the Euro, I'd probably name a 5 digit number, so the deal isn't all that bad. It's just that it doesn't attack the core problem. As long as some members of the union spend much more than they earn, I will have to give them money.
Greece needs to create institutions that are able to tax the rich. Right now they need to take the money from the middle class, because the rich can easily avoid paying. There are jokes about people who own yachts and earn some 20.000 € a year according to government records. I don't think that's all that funny; nor do the Greek people think so.
Right now it seems we go the easy way: Eurobonds. That, of course, solves the current crisis. Unfortunately, it also creates the mother of all moral hazards. If Greek politicians can spend my money without me having any effect on their elections, we are in for a lot of trouble.
Unfortunately, I would have a real problem electing a Greek politician, because he doesn't speak German. Well, I could communicate in English, if he could, but many Germans cannot. The fundamental problem of the European Union remain language barriers. Sadly nobody, certainly not the French, does something about this.
Will it help? Well, yes, for a while. Apparently the euro members want to optimize governance in October. I guess that's something.
Actually, if somebody asked me how much I, personally, was willing to pay for the existence of the Euro, I'd probably name a 5 digit number, so the deal isn't all that bad. It's just that it doesn't attack the core problem. As long as some members of the union spend much more than they earn, I will have to give them money.
Greece needs to create institutions that are able to tax the rich. Right now they need to take the money from the middle class, because the rich can easily avoid paying. There are jokes about people who own yachts and earn some 20.000 € a year according to government records. I don't think that's all that funny; nor do the Greek people think so.
Right now it seems we go the easy way: Eurobonds. That, of course, solves the current crisis. Unfortunately, it also creates the mother of all moral hazards. If Greek politicians can spend my money without me having any effect on their elections, we are in for a lot of trouble.
Unfortunately, I would have a real problem electing a Greek politician, because he doesn't speak German. Well, I could communicate in English, if he could, but many Germans cannot. The fundamental problem of the European Union remain language barriers. Sadly nobody, certainly not the French, does something about this.
Thursday, July 21, 2011
Crysis 2 and Game of Thrones
I've been watching Game of Thrones first season lately and played through Crysis 2 as Post Human Warrior, which is the hardest difficulty. I am not through yet, but my guess is that I am 99% through. A bug made my enemies disappear. Normally that would be a good thing. But since the endgame is scripted, this blocks me from entering the final spike.
My utter despise for heavily scripted content in combination with the bug, made me stop playing somehow.
Anyway, after reading Wolfshead's latest blog post, I decided to spend a few words on the same topic (again): Game of thrones as well as Crysis 2 have a very heavy focus on credibility. Actually, Crysis 2 at this difficulty is quite spectacular. I die as fast as I would expect to and so do my enemies. It's not like Fallout where moving the difficulty slider up means that every enemy survives a complete magazine of headshots.
The only thing you must not do in Crysis 2 is cloak and stealth through every mission. While that is the obvious thing to do, it is clearly not what the designers had in mind. Since this is one clear break with immersion I can live with it.
Within the scripted limits, I found Crysis 2 to be quite fun.
Game of Thrones is good. At least compared to other fantasy TV series. While the beginning is a bit swallow it gets better over time. The nudity and violence make sense, I feel. I do think that 10 episodes is not enough for the content, though. It would have been better for the series to display the same content in 15 or 20 episodes of the same length, I think.
Just like Crysis 2, Game of Thrones has a heavy focus on credibility. There are no extra powerful weapon effects, the shoulder items make sense. The 'heroes' die every now and then and even those who are spectacularly good at what they do (e.g. combat), fail at something else (e.g. illness).
If a fantasy MMORPG allowed me to play a character in the Game of Thrones world (including the graphical style), I'd be more than happy. I don't need the narrative for that. Let me and my fellow players create the story. Just add some external threats and reasons to fight among each other and see the human mind at work.
One thing I find fascinating is the role of distance. In real life I can reach the other end of the world within half a day of boredom. Frankfurt - Shanghai takes no more than 11 hours. How boring our little planet had become once we could fly!
My utter despise for heavily scripted content in combination with the bug, made me stop playing somehow.
Anyway, after reading Wolfshead's latest blog post, I decided to spend a few words on the same topic (again): Game of thrones as well as Crysis 2 have a very heavy focus on credibility. Actually, Crysis 2 at this difficulty is quite spectacular. I die as fast as I would expect to and so do my enemies. It's not like Fallout where moving the difficulty slider up means that every enemy survives a complete magazine of headshots.
The only thing you must not do in Crysis 2 is cloak and stealth through every mission. While that is the obvious thing to do, it is clearly not what the designers had in mind. Since this is one clear break with immersion I can live with it.
Within the scripted limits, I found Crysis 2 to be quite fun.
Game of Thrones is good. At least compared to other fantasy TV series. While the beginning is a bit swallow it gets better over time. The nudity and violence make sense, I feel. I do think that 10 episodes is not enough for the content, though. It would have been better for the series to display the same content in 15 or 20 episodes of the same length, I think.
Just like Crysis 2, Game of Thrones has a heavy focus on credibility. There are no extra powerful weapon effects, the shoulder items make sense. The 'heroes' die every now and then and even those who are spectacularly good at what they do (e.g. combat), fail at something else (e.g. illness).
If a fantasy MMORPG allowed me to play a character in the Game of Thrones world (including the graphical style), I'd be more than happy. I don't need the narrative for that. Let me and my fellow players create the story. Just add some external threats and reasons to fight among each other and see the human mind at work.
One thing I find fascinating is the role of distance. In real life I can reach the other end of the world within half a day of boredom. Frankfurt - Shanghai takes no more than 11 hours. How boring our little planet had become once we could fly!
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
A Parable
Imagine you are on the Titanic. The most powerful vessel of your time. You're a rich guy and have lots of wealth with you. You intend to become even richer once you reach the end of the journey. Until then, however, you have a problem.
You are well connected with the captain and his crew. And so you know that this journey isn't as safe as most people think. In fact, the ship is actually flawed and the decision to take the more dangerous route might be a grave mistake.
The captain and his crew implore you to stay silent. They argue that if you told other people about the weaknesses of the design, a panic might break out. That very panic, they argue, would make it even more probable that something bad happens. For example, some passengers might want to leave the ship and jump on life boats. Since there are not enough life boats, the ship might list heavily.
So you stay silent, but curious. You ask other wealthy passengers. It turns out that everybody admits in private that there is a problem. But then everybody adds that any attempt to get off the boat would be a disaster as well. You are, literally, all in the same boat.
Now, things would be different if you knew that the ship is going to sink. In that case, you would save what little wealth you can and try to get into a life boat before anybody else can. Unfortunately, this is exactly what everybody else is thinking as well. In fact, everybody else is watching you. And you are watching everybody else. And everybody else is watching everybody else. Sometimes somebody makes a suspicious move towards the life boats, but the reasonable guy that you are, you always convince them to stay cool.
As a result, life on the Titanic is nice. Most people successfully repress the notion of any problem at all and enjoy themselves. Actually, it feels as if the subtle knowledge that this journey might be their last, makes life on the Titanic even more relaxed and fun.
Sometimes you wish that you weren't alone on the ocean. Being on a smaller ship, that stays in shallow waters, would allow you to jump the boat and cry for help. While this would make the ship sink much faster, a lot of passengers would start to cry at the sight of even modest problems. Perhaps that would allow the crew to take care of the problems in time? Perhaps all the passengers could work together?
One morning you hear the captain talk about another big ship that you might meet on the journey. The Olympic is a bit older, but otherwise very similar. Unfortunately, it has problems on its own. All the passengers on the Olympic are hopelessly divided, you hear. Even though as a whole the Olympic is much better off than the Titanic, the passengers talk about sinking all the time.
In fact, the Olympic behaves like a flotilla of smaller ships with only a weak common leadership. Passengers are jumping from ship to ship frequently and this already caused some of the smaller ships to be afloat only, because they receive help at pumping out water.
At the evening of the same day you confront the captain with what you heard. Privately, he tells you that you must never speak favorably about the Olympic. For, should the Olympic ever agree to one leader, most people on the Titanic would instantly try to get there. Which would make the Titanic sink for certain. Actually, this might also cause the Olympic to sink!
And then he tells you something you didn't know: There's the Gigantic. A powerful ship which is still under development. You might meet it eventually. However, the Gigantic doesn't allow any other passengers on board. And even if you are on board, they are said to imprison anybody who disagrees with the captain.
Considering your options you agree that the Titanic is your best bet; for now.
You are well connected with the captain and his crew. And so you know that this journey isn't as safe as most people think. In fact, the ship is actually flawed and the decision to take the more dangerous route might be a grave mistake.
The captain and his crew implore you to stay silent. They argue that if you told other people about the weaknesses of the design, a panic might break out. That very panic, they argue, would make it even more probable that something bad happens. For example, some passengers might want to leave the ship and jump on life boats. Since there are not enough life boats, the ship might list heavily.
So you stay silent, but curious. You ask other wealthy passengers. It turns out that everybody admits in private that there is a problem. But then everybody adds that any attempt to get off the boat would be a disaster as well. You are, literally, all in the same boat.
Now, things would be different if you knew that the ship is going to sink. In that case, you would save what little wealth you can and try to get into a life boat before anybody else can. Unfortunately, this is exactly what everybody else is thinking as well. In fact, everybody else is watching you. And you are watching everybody else. And everybody else is watching everybody else. Sometimes somebody makes a suspicious move towards the life boats, but the reasonable guy that you are, you always convince them to stay cool.
As a result, life on the Titanic is nice. Most people successfully repress the notion of any problem at all and enjoy themselves. Actually, it feels as if the subtle knowledge that this journey might be their last, makes life on the Titanic even more relaxed and fun.
Sometimes you wish that you weren't alone on the ocean. Being on a smaller ship, that stays in shallow waters, would allow you to jump the boat and cry for help. While this would make the ship sink much faster, a lot of passengers would start to cry at the sight of even modest problems. Perhaps that would allow the crew to take care of the problems in time? Perhaps all the passengers could work together?
One morning you hear the captain talk about another big ship that you might meet on the journey. The Olympic is a bit older, but otherwise very similar. Unfortunately, it has problems on its own. All the passengers on the Olympic are hopelessly divided, you hear. Even though as a whole the Olympic is much better off than the Titanic, the passengers talk about sinking all the time.
In fact, the Olympic behaves like a flotilla of smaller ships with only a weak common leadership. Passengers are jumping from ship to ship frequently and this already caused some of the smaller ships to be afloat only, because they receive help at pumping out water.
At the evening of the same day you confront the captain with what you heard. Privately, he tells you that you must never speak favorably about the Olympic. For, should the Olympic ever agree to one leader, most people on the Titanic would instantly try to get there. Which would make the Titanic sink for certain. Actually, this might also cause the Olympic to sink!
And then he tells you something you didn't know: There's the Gigantic. A powerful ship which is still under development. You might meet it eventually. However, the Gigantic doesn't allow any other passengers on board. And even if you are on board, they are said to imprison anybody who disagrees with the captain.
Considering your options you agree that the Titanic is your best bet; for now.
Risk
Before I made this blog I actually made another blog for a few months. It was mostly in German, and is thus useless to most of you. I just re-read the first blog entry I ever wrote and found it was in English. I decided to modify it a bit and copy/paste it here. It's not really about politics, but it is about everything politics is about.
(1)
One million years BC. Imagine 10,000 isolated communities on earth, each the home of up to 100 humans. Humanity evolved in this situation and therefore it is logical to assume that we, individually, evolved in a way that we intuitively maximise the probability of survival of humanity as a whole in this situation.
Maximising the probability of survival means adjusting risks. This is comparable to stock exchange markets. A high risk generally leads to higher expected returns in the long run, but also has a higher chance of total loss. In a 10,000 communities situation, the whole of humanity maximises the probability of survival if - and only if - the individual community takes greater risks than were sensible in a one-community situation. The total loss of one community every 1000 years, for example, is anything but dramatic if the higher risk leads to 5 addition communities during this time span. This explains the fact that the human mind ignores risks of low probability even if the consequences are dramatic..
Although the threat of a nuclear war, deadly viruses or even an asteroid hitting our planet have the potential to destroy our entire species, the human mind does not emotionally acknowledge them as dangerous. The probability is too low and evolution taught us to ignore low-probability risks, even if they could potentially destroy the entire community.
What has changed, of course, is the number of communities. With globalization advancing, many low-probability risks suddenly endanger all of humanity, as we are about to live in one single gobal community.
(2)
Almost no major milestone in human history ever was exspected. This applies to the fall of Rome, Martin Luther nailing 95 Theses to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg, the economic crisis in 1929, the effect nuclear bombs would have on politics, the race to the moon, the fall of the Berlin Wall, the destruction of the World Trade Center and its consequences and even the current economic crisis. It also applies to the significance of electricity, telephones, cars, personal computers, the internet and mobile phones (click).
One major strength of our economic system is pluralism. We do not collect the smartest of our kind and ask them to think about how to create the future, but instead encourage everybody to open a business and try it out. In the past we did the same with political systems.
Humanity never was able to predict where itself was going. Whenever we tried - and several political systems did try - we miserably failed.
(3)
The inablity to predict almost any milestone in human evolution, combined with the inablity to intuitively judge risks in a globalized world, is essential to acknowledge!
It is this inability alone that warns humanity about the attempt to create a world with one goverment. The obvious benefits, like a decreased number of wars and more cultural understanding, are dwarfed by the unknown number of unknown low-probability risks that might cause the end of the world as we know it.
(4)
Independent of globalization, some risks apply to our entire species. If the human mind, that individually experiences no more than 100 years, wants to make a difference in the greater scheme of things, it has to venture beyond earth and distribute risks.
(1)
One million years BC. Imagine 10,000 isolated communities on earth, each the home of up to 100 humans. Humanity evolved in this situation and therefore it is logical to assume that we, individually, evolved in a way that we intuitively maximise the probability of survival of humanity as a whole in this situation.
Maximising the probability of survival means adjusting risks. This is comparable to stock exchange markets. A high risk generally leads to higher expected returns in the long run, but also has a higher chance of total loss. In a 10,000 communities situation, the whole of humanity maximises the probability of survival if - and only if - the individual community takes greater risks than were sensible in a one-community situation. The total loss of one community every 1000 years, for example, is anything but dramatic if the higher risk leads to 5 addition communities during this time span. This explains the fact that the human mind ignores risks of low probability even if the consequences are dramatic..
Although the threat of a nuclear war, deadly viruses or even an asteroid hitting our planet have the potential to destroy our entire species, the human mind does not emotionally acknowledge them as dangerous. The probability is too low and evolution taught us to ignore low-probability risks, even if they could potentially destroy the entire community.
What has changed, of course, is the number of communities. With globalization advancing, many low-probability risks suddenly endanger all of humanity, as we are about to live in one single gobal community.
(2)
Almost no major milestone in human history ever was exspected. This applies to the fall of Rome, Martin Luther nailing 95 Theses to the door of the Castle Church in Wittenberg, the economic crisis in 1929, the effect nuclear bombs would have on politics, the race to the moon, the fall of the Berlin Wall, the destruction of the World Trade Center and its consequences and even the current economic crisis. It also applies to the significance of electricity, telephones, cars, personal computers, the internet and mobile phones (click).
One major strength of our economic system is pluralism. We do not collect the smartest of our kind and ask them to think about how to create the future, but instead encourage everybody to open a business and try it out. In the past we did the same with political systems.
Humanity never was able to predict where itself was going. Whenever we tried - and several political systems did try - we miserably failed.
(3)
The inablity to predict almost any milestone in human evolution, combined with the inablity to intuitively judge risks in a globalized world, is essential to acknowledge!
It is this inability alone that warns humanity about the attempt to create a world with one goverment. The obvious benefits, like a decreased number of wars and more cultural understanding, are dwarfed by the unknown number of unknown low-probability risks that might cause the end of the world as we know it.
(4)
Independent of globalization, some risks apply to our entire species. If the human mind, that individually experiences no more than 100 years, wants to make a difference in the greater scheme of things, it has to venture beyond earth and distribute risks.
Tuesday, July 19, 2011
Dear Readers
Dear readers,
as you know I don't really have many MMO topics to blog about recently. The industry is just not producing the games I would like to play. This may change eventually, and I certainly hope so. Until then I will switch to a politics blog.
Unfortunately, the blog's name doesn't make much sense then; nor does it make a lot of sense to be listed in all kinds of MMO-blogrolls, when you write about non-MMO stuff.
I thought about two options. One is to create the "Nils' Politics Blog" and link it from here, because I certainly want to take a few readers with me. Blogging without readers is boring. The second option is change this blog into a blog about MMOs, politics and economics. I can change everything except for the URL to be "Nils' Blog".
To say this very clearly: I am not quitting MMO blogging. I am just having a break.
Anyway, what do you think I should do ?
as you know I don't really have many MMO topics to blog about recently. The industry is just not producing the games I would like to play. This may change eventually, and I certainly hope so. Until then I will switch to a politics blog.
Unfortunately, the blog's name doesn't make much sense then; nor does it make a lot of sense to be listed in all kinds of MMO-blogrolls, when you write about non-MMO stuff.
I thought about two options. One is to create the "Nils' Politics Blog" and link it from here, because I certainly want to take a few readers with me. Blogging without readers is boring. The second option is change this blog into a blog about MMOs, politics and economics. I can change everything except for the URL to be "Nils' Blog".
To say this very clearly: I am not quitting MMO blogging. I am just having a break.
Anyway, what do you think I should do ?
Saturday, July 16, 2011
On European Debt
[[Once again a political post]]
While the U.S. are involved in serious political fights right now, so is Europe. Interestingly, the European media cover the U.S. debt crisis only a bit, and the U.S. media almost completely ignore the European debt crisis.
What's also very interesting is that most articles in the U.S. say that Europe is clearly in decline right now. And most articles in Europe say that U.S. is clearly in decline right now.
Since quite some readers of this blog live in the U.S. I decided to make a post on the European situation. Of course, I'm just an interested non-professional. Remember that before you invest your retirement provisions. :)
Debt crises are only partly about facts; they are mostly about trust. In fact, trust is a fact. In 2010 the EU had a public debt of 85% and a running deficit of 6.4% of GDP. This is much, much better than the U.S., because EU revenue is 44% of GDP. Thus, only about 12% of the public spending is debt-financed, whereas 40% of U.S. public spending is debt-financed. Also, the EU has exported about 1.350 trillion € and imported 1.500 trillion € in 2010 which is way more balanced than in the U.S. (link)
Europe's problem is trust. And it is trust that makes the European crisis more dangerous than the U.S. crisis right now. Also, the European debt crisis is much more difficult to understand than the U.S. one - even for Europeans. But just like in the U.S. there are two basic positions. (Humanity is all about dualisms, isn't it?).
1) Just let the states go broke and save the banks when necessary.
2) Just introduce Euro-bonds so that all states pay for each other indefinitely.
Both positions are no solutions: they are ideologies.
If Europe allowed states to go broke, there is a high chance that the world would drown in flames for a decade and more as more and more banks and then nations needed to be saved while stopping the chain-reaction.
And for a nation to put the trust back into the banking system, it needs to be financially stable. Neither the U.S. nor the EU are anywhere financially stable enough to save a few hundred more banks right now.
On the other hand, while introduction of Euro-bonds would instantly solve the immediate problem, it would also bring along gigantic moral hazards. Greece could suddenly spend money that German tax-payers would need to pay - indefinitely. And the German taxpayers wouldn't be able to (de-)elect the Greece politicians that spend their money!
Moreover, while transfer of wealth is part of every nation, it requires an understanding of 'togetherness'; a common bond. The common bond is not sufficiently strong right now in Europe; mostly because we speak different languages and don't have visible political leaders.
What European and German leaders do right now is a middle course. A very dirty middle course! And I support that. If anything, you can blame politicians for not communicating their strategies to the constituency. But this very communication might actually make it harder or even impossible to go the middle course! Muddling through is what has to be done right now - unfortunately.
Europe will not fall apart due to this crisis. Just like the U.S. will not fall apart due to the tea party. Europe will eventually finish muddling through. Only then comes the really dangerous part! The European Union will have to become more resistant against debt crises. There are two ways to do that:
1) More integration: German taxpayers can elect the politicians that spend money in Greece and vice versa.
2) Separation: A northern EU and a southern EU.
I like (1) more. In the 21st century I want to be able to elect politicians that have global power. Unfortunately, (1) is also the less probable option. A lot depends on the next German and French elections! Major parts of the German opposition prefer (1) as well.
However, more likely is (2) and we can only hope that this process will be peaceful - especially in southern Europe that would suffer a drastic drop in wealth.
Of course, this is just the known unknown. Any revolution in China, war in the middle east (oil price shocks) or major terror attack can change the course of history and violently push us into the unknown unknown. It is going to become an interesting century! - just like the last one.
While the U.S. are involved in serious political fights right now, so is Europe. Interestingly, the European media cover the U.S. debt crisis only a bit, and the U.S. media almost completely ignore the European debt crisis.
What's also very interesting is that most articles in the U.S. say that Europe is clearly in decline right now. And most articles in Europe say that U.S. is clearly in decline right now.
Since quite some readers of this blog live in the U.S. I decided to make a post on the European situation. Of course, I'm just an interested non-professional. Remember that before you invest your retirement provisions. :)
Debt crises are only partly about facts; they are mostly about trust. In fact, trust is a fact. In 2010 the EU had a public debt of 85% and a running deficit of 6.4% of GDP. This is much, much better than the U.S., because EU revenue is 44% of GDP. Thus, only about 12% of the public spending is debt-financed, whereas 40% of U.S. public spending is debt-financed. Also, the EU has exported about 1.350 trillion € and imported 1.500 trillion € in 2010 which is way more balanced than in the U.S. (link)
Europe's problem is trust. And it is trust that makes the European crisis more dangerous than the U.S. crisis right now. Also, the European debt crisis is much more difficult to understand than the U.S. one - even for Europeans. But just like in the U.S. there are two basic positions. (Humanity is all about dualisms, isn't it?).
1) Just let the states go broke and save the banks when necessary.
2) Just introduce Euro-bonds so that all states pay for each other indefinitely.
Both positions are no solutions: they are ideologies.
If Europe allowed states to go broke, there is a high chance that the world would drown in flames for a decade and more as more and more banks and then nations needed to be saved while stopping the chain-reaction.
And for a nation to put the trust back into the banking system, it needs to be financially stable. Neither the U.S. nor the EU are anywhere financially stable enough to save a few hundred more banks right now.
On the other hand, while introduction of Euro-bonds would instantly solve the immediate problem, it would also bring along gigantic moral hazards. Greece could suddenly spend money that German tax-payers would need to pay - indefinitely. And the German taxpayers wouldn't be able to (de-)elect the Greece politicians that spend their money!
Moreover, while transfer of wealth is part of every nation, it requires an understanding of 'togetherness'; a common bond. The common bond is not sufficiently strong right now in Europe; mostly because we speak different languages and don't have visible political leaders.
What European and German leaders do right now is a middle course. A very dirty middle course! And I support that. If anything, you can blame politicians for not communicating their strategies to the constituency. But this very communication might actually make it harder or even impossible to go the middle course! Muddling through is what has to be done right now - unfortunately.
Europe will not fall apart due to this crisis. Just like the U.S. will not fall apart due to the tea party. Europe will eventually finish muddling through. Only then comes the really dangerous part! The European Union will have to become more resistant against debt crises. There are two ways to do that:
1) More integration: German taxpayers can elect the politicians that spend money in Greece and vice versa.
2) Separation: A northern EU and a southern EU.
I like (1) more. In the 21st century I want to be able to elect politicians that have global power. Unfortunately, (1) is also the less probable option. A lot depends on the next German and French elections! Major parts of the German opposition prefer (1) as well.
However, more likely is (2) and we can only hope that this process will be peaceful - especially in southern Europe that would suffer a drastic drop in wealth.
Of course, this is just the known unknown. Any revolution in China, war in the middle east (oil price shocks) or major terror attack can change the course of history and violently push us into the unknown unknown. It is going to become an interesting century! - just like the last one.
Wednesday, July 13, 2011
Losing vs. Winning
There's not a strong connection here to current MMORPGs, games and gamification. But enough of a connection to link it.
Monday, July 11, 2011
The Future is All Around Us
You know, politics should be as credible and consistent as possible and as little as necessary. Just like MMOs, it's not.
But since MMOs are still boring as hell, I'll just blog about whatever comes to my mind. Just consider real life a really stunning MMO until GW2 or so.
Also, I am in an adventurous mood right now, which is why I will predict three things.
1) Republicans will eventually offer a 90 day compromise. The president will reject it, arguing that things won't be easier in 90 days, but rather much harder, since the election is even nearer. He will then cite the 14th amendment and order Mr. Geithner to ignore congress. There will be a lot of crying going on. But since Republicans know very well that this is the best possible way out of the hole they dug, they will accept it.
2) Italy will not go broke. But my chancellor will continue giving my money away. In a few years a lot of anti-europe parties will be elected in EU countries. A few weeks after this has happened in France, four countries (Germany, Netherlands, Austria and Finland plus some smaller ones) will "declare independence" and create a "new euro zone". There will be some havoc in southern Europe, but no civil wars.
3) A few years later China goes up in fire and, as a consequence, so does the rest of the world.
Have a nice week ;)
But since MMOs are still boring as hell, I'll just blog about whatever comes to my mind. Just consider real life a really stunning MMO until GW2 or so.
Also, I am in an adventurous mood right now, which is why I will predict three things.
1) Republicans will eventually offer a 90 day compromise. The president will reject it, arguing that things won't be easier in 90 days, but rather much harder, since the election is even nearer. He will then cite the 14th amendment and order Mr. Geithner to ignore congress. There will be a lot of crying going on. But since Republicans know very well that this is the best possible way out of the hole they dug, they will accept it.
2) Italy will not go broke. But my chancellor will continue giving my money away. In a few years a lot of anti-europe parties will be elected in EU countries. A few weeks after this has happened in France, four countries (Germany, Netherlands, Austria and Finland plus some smaller ones) will "declare independence" and create a "new euro zone". There will be some havoc in southern Europe, but no civil wars.
3) A few years later China goes up in fire and, as a consequence, so does the rest of the world.
Have a nice week ;)
Saturday, July 9, 2011
Taxes and the Economy
[[This post is not about computer games]]
Reading US media and the lovely comments sections, there's something I don't get. About half of you people seem to think that raising taxes has a bad effect on the economy. Laffer curves and things like that. Now, I agree that 100% taxes is bad for the economy.
But for realistic tax rates, there's really not much of a relationship.
Want proof? Just have a look outside the US.
A Swedish web site or Wikipedia
Let's take Denmark as an example. They lead most lists by 'stealing' about 50% of their citizens' income a year. And here's the 2010 GDP: $56,147 per capita.
The US 'steal' 24% of their citizens' income each year. Their 2010 GDP: $47,284 per capita.
You can compare GDP in PPP terms to get less extreme results. But the truth is: I have a sister in the US and their standard of living is just the same we have in Germany. But here the taxes are a lot higher. I payed 50% in taxes and social security contributions last year.
Yet Germany's economy soars, matching annualized 6% last quarter. Unemployment has never been lower in re-united Germany than today.
Reading US media and the lovely comments sections, there's something I don't get. About half of you people seem to think that raising taxes has a bad effect on the economy. Laffer curves and things like that. Now, I agree that 100% taxes is bad for the economy.
But for realistic tax rates, there's really not much of a relationship.
Want proof? Just have a look outside the US.
A Swedish web site or Wikipedia
Let's take Denmark as an example. They lead most lists by 'stealing' about 50% of their citizens' income a year. And here's the 2010 GDP: $56,147 per capita.
The US 'steal' 24% of their citizens' income each year. Their 2010 GDP: $47,284 per capita.
You can compare GDP in PPP terms to get less extreme results. But the truth is: I have a sister in the US and their standard of living is just the same we have in Germany. But here the taxes are a lot higher. I payed 50% in taxes and social security contributions last year.
Yet Germany's economy soars, matching annualized 6% last quarter. Unemployment has never been lower in re-united Germany than today.
Friday, July 8, 2011
Failure at what ?
Armadillo has made a post related to my recent series about death penalties. In the comments section I read something that I have read quite often already:
Actually, I agree. I just ask: Failure at what?
Failure to not die to the last blow? Let's rewind until before that blow.
Failure to not die during the last 10 seconds? Let's rewind the last 10 seconds.
Failure to not die to a mob? Let's reset the mob.
Failure to not die in one encounter? Let's reset the encounter.
Failure to not die in a dungeon? Let's reset the dungeon.
Failure to not die with while playing a fantasy character? Let's reset the character.
Failure to not die while playing a RPG? Let's reset until before you owned the game.
Failure to not die with a fantasy character while living real life? Let's send the death squad.
I think failure is not just enough of a penalty. I think failure is the penalty!
"Failure is enough of a penalty"
Actually, I agree. I just ask: Failure at what?
Failure to not die to the last blow? Let's rewind until before that blow.
Failure to not die during the last 10 seconds? Let's rewind the last 10 seconds.
Failure to not die to a mob? Let's reset the mob.
Failure to not die in one encounter? Let's reset the encounter.
Failure to not die in a dungeon? Let's reset the dungeon.
Failure to not die with while playing a fantasy character? Let's reset the character.
Failure to not die while playing a RPG? Let's reset until before you owned the game.
Failure to not die with a fantasy character while living real life? Let's send the death squad.
I think failure is not just enough of a penalty. I think failure is the penalty!
Thursday, July 7, 2011
Abstract Games
Yesterday I stumbled upon this game. A wonderful combination of strategy, execution and some really nasty tricks on the designer's part. .. Careful, it's highly addictive.
Oh - and try to beat me ;)
Oh - and try to beat me ;)
Wednesday, July 6, 2011
Computer Games and Art #2
Thanks to everybody for that very nice discussion in the last post! For the record, I agree that the "loss is required for great art" hypothesis is not tenable. Suggestions, that have been given in the last post, to replace it with "conflict" or "change" are good. But they might also be a bit too obvious.
At least we all agree that great art induces great emotions. But let me ask you a few more questions:
1) Do you think that narratives are the only way for computer games to create great emotions?
2) Do you think that the dominant emotion induced by all computer games is that of "gain" / "achievement" / "fulfillment of dreams" ?
3) Are there any computer games that, in your opinion, are equal to art in other domains?
Before you answer that last question, refresh your taste of great art here and conclude it by putting your headphones on your ears, double the volume(!), darken the room and listen to this interpretation.
At least we all agree that great art induces great emotions. But let me ask you a few more questions:
1) Do you think that narratives are the only way for computer games to create great emotions?
2) Do you think that the dominant emotion induced by all computer games is that of "gain" / "achievement" / "fulfillment of dreams" ?
3) Are there any computer games that, in your opinion, are equal to art in other domains?
Before you answer that last question, refresh your taste of great art here and conclude it by putting your headphones on your ears, double the volume(!), darken the room and listen to this interpretation.
Computer Games are Art ?
The White Whale swam before him as the monomaniac incarnation of all those malicious agencies which some deep men feel eating in them, till they are left living on with half a heart and half a lung. That intangible malignity which has been from the beginning; to whose dominion even the modern Christians ascribe one-half of the worlds; which the ancient Ophites of the east reverenced in their statue devil; -- Ahab did not fall down and worship it like them; but deliriously transferring its idea to the abhorred white whale, he pitted himself, all mutilated, against it. All that most maddens and torments; all that stirs up the lees of things; all truth with malice in it; all that cracks the sinews and cakes the brain; all the subtle demonisms of life and thought; all evil, to crazy Ahab, were visibly personified, and made practically assailable in Moby-Dick. He piled upon the whale's white hump the sum of all the general rage and hate felt by his whole race from Adam down; and then, as if his chest had been a mortar, he burst his hot heart's shell upon it.
Art requires great emotions. Great emotions require loss. Loss is what all computer games try to avoid like the pest. I don't think it is impossible to make a computer game great art. But we aren't anywhere close.
Sunday, July 3, 2011
Convenience Functionalities
Lately we had several heated debates on this blog about micro-transaction-based business models for MMORPGs. My main two arguments against were these:
1) The business models corrupt players and, more importantly, the company.
2) The business models damage the "immersion" and the consistency of the simulation aspect.
1)
During the debates the advocates tried a lot of arguments to convince me. And I like that. I may not always react in an obviously grateful manner, but I wouldn't have a blog with enabled comments if I disliked controversial conversations.
Theoretically, at least, point (1) is easy to defuse. And when it comes to point (2) commenters asked what my opinion is on convenience items. I didn't respond to that immediately which is always a sign that it is a good point.
Let's imagine a WoW-like MMORPG with a leveling game. Does a +25% experience functionality, available for micro-transactions, harm immersion? Well, a bit, sure. But if the developers hid it from me that other players use it; does it harm immersion?
What I know is that my first reaction to this functionality is strongly negative. But it isn't all that easy to find a good reason. One reason might be that other players will inevitably start to talk about it. But since the WoW-like leveling is designed to be a single player experience, that's not that much of a problem really.
Of course, the pure theoretical knowledge that such a thing exists does harm immersion for me. Circumstances matter. But is that really the biggest problem?
2)
After thinking about it really hard I arrived at a rather surprising conclusion: The biggest problem about convenience functionalities, that you can buy for micro-transactions, aren't the micro-transactions! The problem is that they exist in the first place.
Actually, I remember that I wanted to post about this for quite some months: To offer convenience to your players is a terrible, terrible mistake; even if it doesn't cost any €. The reason is that by adding such functionalities (like heirlooms), you send a very clear message to the players.
The message is: "This activity is not meant to be fun!".
Players react to "meant to be"-messages very clearly; especially if they are convincing. For example, telling your players that you don't really care that much about balance, is powerful. It can instantly cut the balance complains in half (no, they won't go away). On the other hand, telling your players that you want to make the perfectly balanced game, will get you into trouble.
Within limits, players subconsciously trust developers. That might not be obvious and I see some developers laughing back there, but it is the truth. It's similar to a politician approaching me and telling me that I am correct about all these problems with Greece, but they thought about it extensively and what they do now is the lesser evil. It is called leadership. It's what will happen when republicans eventually tell their constituency that a small tax increase for the rich was necessary for the greater good and isn't a harbinger of Armageddon.
Players can easily become upset if developers don't meet the goals they set themselves. But we are much more tolerant when it comes to declaring the developers' goals to be wrong.
More powerful than direct messages, however, are indirect messages. The reason is that they are obviously truthful.
3)
If you want to make a new character in WoW, you are confronted with the following question: "Do you want to experience the stories during leveling, or do you want to get it over with as fast as possible".
That's, by the way, a good example for the fact that not every interesting decision is good for your game!
As if it wasn't already bad enough, what's especially harmful is that "getting it over with" costs something. This is what very effectively convinces players that it has to be more fun. (Which it is usually not, by the way.)
This is a problem for any convenience functionality. If players can acquire convenience that is not otherwise justified by, i.e. the simulation, they subconsciously conclude that the only reason for its existence is to remedy inconvenience. And that necessarily means that the developer considers the activity in question to be inconvenient.
This not only automatically motivates the question, why the developer wants them to suffer. 25% faster is not nearly fast enough if the activity is inconvenient! It also very effectively convinces the players that something is not fun, even though they might have had fun before they knew about the convenience functionality.
4)
Summing up: Convenience functionalities very effectively convince players that your game is meant to be inconvenient. That should get you worried.
1) The business models corrupt players and, more importantly, the company.
2) The business models damage the "immersion" and the consistency of the simulation aspect.
1)
During the debates the advocates tried a lot of arguments to convince me. And I like that. I may not always react in an obviously grateful manner, but I wouldn't have a blog with enabled comments if I disliked controversial conversations.
Theoretically, at least, point (1) is easy to defuse. And when it comes to point (2) commenters asked what my opinion is on convenience items. I didn't respond to that immediately which is always a sign that it is a good point.
Let's imagine a WoW-like MMORPG with a leveling game. Does a +25% experience functionality, available for micro-transactions, harm immersion? Well, a bit, sure. But if the developers hid it from me that other players use it; does it harm immersion?
What I know is that my first reaction to this functionality is strongly negative. But it isn't all that easy to find a good reason. One reason might be that other players will inevitably start to talk about it. But since the WoW-like leveling is designed to be a single player experience, that's not that much of a problem really.
Of course, the pure theoretical knowledge that such a thing exists does harm immersion for me. Circumstances matter. But is that really the biggest problem?
2)
After thinking about it really hard I arrived at a rather surprising conclusion: The biggest problem about convenience functionalities, that you can buy for micro-transactions, aren't the micro-transactions! The problem is that they exist in the first place.
Actually, I remember that I wanted to post about this for quite some months: To offer convenience to your players is a terrible, terrible mistake; even if it doesn't cost any €. The reason is that by adding such functionalities (like heirlooms), you send a very clear message to the players.
The message is: "This activity is not meant to be fun!".
Players react to "meant to be"-messages very clearly; especially if they are convincing. For example, telling your players that you don't really care that much about balance, is powerful. It can instantly cut the balance complains in half (no, they won't go away). On the other hand, telling your players that you want to make the perfectly balanced game, will get you into trouble.
Within limits, players subconsciously trust developers. That might not be obvious and I see some developers laughing back there, but it is the truth. It's similar to a politician approaching me and telling me that I am correct about all these problems with Greece, but they thought about it extensively and what they do now is the lesser evil. It is called leadership. It's what will happen when republicans eventually tell their constituency that a small tax increase for the rich was necessary for the greater good and isn't a harbinger of Armageddon.
Players can easily become upset if developers don't meet the goals they set themselves. But we are much more tolerant when it comes to declaring the developers' goals to be wrong.
More powerful than direct messages, however, are indirect messages. The reason is that they are obviously truthful.
3)
If you want to make a new character in WoW, you are confronted with the following question: "Do you want to experience the stories during leveling, or do you want to get it over with as fast as possible".
That's, by the way, a good example for the fact that not every interesting decision is good for your game!
As if it wasn't already bad enough, what's especially harmful is that "getting it over with" costs something. This is what very effectively convinces players that it has to be more fun. (Which it is usually not, by the way.)
This is a problem for any convenience functionality. If players can acquire convenience that is not otherwise justified by, i.e. the simulation, they subconsciously conclude that the only reason for its existence is to remedy inconvenience. And that necessarily means that the developer considers the activity in question to be inconvenient.
This not only automatically motivates the question, why the developer wants them to suffer. 25% faster is not nearly fast enough if the activity is inconvenient! It also very effectively convinces the players that something is not fun, even though they might have had fun before they knew about the convenience functionality.
4)
Summing up: Convenience functionalities very effectively convince players that your game is meant to be inconvenient. That should get you worried.
Thursday, June 30, 2011
Little break and some chewing gum
I can't post the next few days. Considering my recent frequency that's a break I announce.
To give you something to chew on, here's a comment Furdinand left on a post at Massively:
---
Added Marketing by Raph Koster to the Really Interesting Links.
To give you something to chew on, here's a comment Furdinand left on a post at Massively:
I remember thinking when Ultima Online and Everquest first came out that games were on the threshold of bringing the pen and paper RPG experience online. Big, open worlds to explore with random danger and adventures. I expected that we would eventually see something like a living room Forgotten Realms campaign with hundreds of thousands of players and DMs.
Now it's 2011 and D&D is on the threshold of being an offline WoW instead.
---
Added Marketing by Raph Koster to the Really Interesting Links.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
